Just now, Cory Caboose said:

Well, I think I did call you a wolf

 

But more in a "explain yourself" then a "you must die!" kind of way yanno

you definitely mentioned drawing lines in the sand lol

 

it reminded me of when you and idr outed me in SA tbh. Just I didn’t go dark this time 

4 minutes ago, SinisterDeath said:

If you read back, I mentioned this is like game #5. 2 this year, 3 over a decade ago.

 

I know I self voted in at least 3 games, one of which I was wolf. Got lynched D1 as wolf. Longest I made it was D2 before lynch. Night capped, etc.

Username bias was also a factor in the early days. 

It was less the self vote and mostly everything that came before that.  the self vote just seemed like more confirmation from my POV.  But if you say you self vote as either alignment, okay, i guess. (but mostly, self voting is gross and almost always anti-town).  

1 minute ago, whiskey delta said:

You think Clov will flip town? Why

I dunno if Clov will flip town. Could be wolf. You could be wolf. Darthe could be wolf. Tripped could be wolf. 

Well I'm glad you've been very villagery today

Just now, TrippedOnReality said:

It was less the self vote and mostly everything that came before that.  the self vote just seemed like more confirmation from my POV.  But if you say you self vote as either alignment, okay, i guess. (but mostly, self voting is gross and almost always anti-town).  

From the times I've played, sometimes it felt better to just get hammered and jump into dead chat, then it was to waste 36 hours bickering on my wagon without any of the posts helping figure out others alignments. 

On 7/10/2022 at 9:10 PM, SinisterDeath said:

 

Interesting.

Assuming derf = Darthe, we have a potential team of Darthe, Tripped, and Cory.

From what interaction I've had with Zander, his D1 reads were the exact opposite of what happened.
Zander thought Dice was Town and I was Wolf. Opposite was true. 😉 
 

 

On 7/10/2022 at 9:03 PM, SinisterDeath said:

Who should we absolutely not lunch?

 

On 7/11/2022 at 2:42 PM, SinisterDeath said:

We're working opposite goals here lmao

 

On 7/11/2022 at 10:07 AM, SinisterDeath said:

How is this not Wolfy? 🙂

 

On 7/11/2022 at 9:55 AM, SinisterDeath said:

Exactly what a wolf would say. 

 

Okay, so the short of it is: SD made it very clear he didn't trust Zander and even in a world where he did, he didn't think Zander had good reads based on their last game which is his experience in mafia.  It's then notable that Zander voted Leelou 3 posts before he voted Dice.  

 

 

On 7/12/2022 at 6:53 PM, SinisterDeath said:

@Darthe

If Cory was wolf, do you think he'd take out Zander, thinking he was a Vig? (I seem to think Zander lying about being a vig?)

 

I also remember Verb claiming he'd vig Zander.

 

If a doc saved someone from the wolf, then we can assume the Vig took out Zander.  Right? 

 

Last thing here.  This post?  Yeah this post came almost a full day before the vig claim.  

 

11 hours ago, Verbal32 said:

Ok, caught up.

 

And yes, I shot Zander.  Roleclaim:  town vigilante

 

Honestly, I thought he had a good chance at being scum.  Didn't like our back & forth and really thought he was going to flip scum and I'd do a little dance.

 

What do we know?  That the Doc (assuming that's Cory because no cc as of yet) blocked the scum NK, or the scum didn't shoot after seeing me post about vigging Zander D1.  I would imagine that's less likely, as scum would want dead bodies, so I'm going with Doc blocking the NK.

 

I usually holster N1 as a vig unless I feel confident, which is why I fired.  lolme

 

30 minutes ago, TrippedOnReality said:

 

Yes, I think he's more likely to be town than not based on his interactions with me last night and just generally being on the same page with our reads most of the game.  But I've absolutely gotten crushed by mafia!Chris pretty much every time he's been mafia against me, so I could be wrong.    

See, this I don't like particularly.  Everyone, and I do mean everyone, is more likely to be town than mafia. That's the point of the game.  You keep saying you can't read clov as a wolf at all, that you've never done it successfully, but this is the first time I've gotten you to clearly say you think he's town and it's because I pushed you into it.  I think it's interesting that you think you can townread him well but not wolfread him, yet in a game where you're not clearly townreading him you aren't using that as a tell that he could be a wolf, and when pushed you default to town.  Does that make sense?

7 minutes ago, Cory Caboose said:

Well I'm glad you've been very villagery today

btw the ego comment wasn’t meant to be mean so hopefully that didn’t come across the wrong way

 

did you finish your reread?

From all of this my takeaway is that sinister is a bit lost, and that they should never make it to f3, but I'd not want to lynch them.  If they were a wolf they basically committed suicide, barring that this is some intense bus play from verb and their wolf team was inactive d1.  But again, those are the sorts of fringe scenarios we don't humor.

Darthe I think your evaluation metric might be too high here. I won’t deny SD looks bad from a “typical” town standpoint but I also think that’s not gonna work for this slot

 

if it flips wolf then I guess that’s on me but I don’t see it. I thought their stuff today chewing on the claims and how they might interact were good. Not unfakeable but legit effort into at least pretending to think

 

its better than the content from others this phase imo

 

Not WTL

 

Darthe

VooDoo

Delta

Tripped

 

Not today

 

Hallia

Verb

 

Would feel good but probably not optimal

 

SinisterDeath

 

Resolution desired

 

Leelou

Clov

Oh nvm then

 

sick x post 

1 minute ago, whiskey delta said:

Darthe I think your evaluation metric might be too high here. I won’t deny SD looks bad from a “typical” town standpoint but I also think that’s not gonna work for this slot

 

if it flips wolf then I guess that’s on me but I don’t see it. I thought their stuff today chewing on the claims and how they might interact were good. Not unfakeable but legit effort into at least pretending to think

 

its better than the content from others this phase imo

 

Lol I think you x-posted my post.  I think the slot's town.

2 minutes ago, whiskey delta said:

did you finish your reread?

 

Nope. I may continue it but its been a bad focus day. It might help me get unstuck on my reads a lil.

Darthe-esque paranoia post:
 

Spoiler

Really, no need to read this.  

Spoiler

I recognize that we lose this game if AJs a wolf, and I accept that.  Don't think the thought hasn't crossed my mind, I just think it's like 80/20 clov over him, and I don't wanna detract from that.  

 

5 minutes ago, Cory Caboose said:

Leelou

Clov

I think I could chew on that for D2.

Let Verb Vig me tonight? 

Vote Clov

See y'all in the mornin'

2 minutes ago, Darthe said:

See, this I don't like particularly.  Everyone, and I do mean everyone, is more likely to be town than mafia. That's the point of the game.  You keep saying you can't read clov as a wolf at all, that you've never done it successfully, but this is the first time I've gotten you to clearly say you think he's town and it's because I pushed you into it.  I think it's interesting that you think you can townread him well but not wolfread him, yet in a game where you're not clearly townreading him you aren't using that as a tell that he could be a wolf, and when pushed you default to town.  Does that make sense?

 

The only time I've clearly ever town read him is after he yeeted mafia.  that hasn't happened yet, so I'm not sure what you want me to say.  Is there a world he could be mafia?  absolutely.  you asked for my read on him, so I gave it.  The reason I didn't want to make it is because I know that I'm not good at reading him before he's done something significant.  My approach to Chris most games is basically let him do his thing, see where it goes.  If his reads are lining up with mine great, if not, we usually try to hash them out.  If he's town, we've had high success with catching mafia and work really well together.  The problem is, up until we actually yeet mafia, it's kind of a "I'm going to treat you as town until I think I shouldn't."  Except the first game we ever played together, mafia!Chris has shot me N1 or N2. 

Get Clov to L-1 and get outta the way 

i think he is l-1.  dont vote yet just to be safe

10 minutes ago, TrippedOnReality said:

 

The only time I've clearly ever town read him is after he yeeted mafia.  that hasn't happened yet, so I'm not sure what you want me to say.  Is there a world he could be mafia?  absolutely.  you asked for my read on him, so I gave it.  The reason I didn't want to make it is because I know that I'm not good at reading him before he's done something significant.  My approach to Chris most games is basically let him do his thing, see where it goes.  If his reads are lining up with mine great, if not, we usually try to hash them out.  If he's town, we've had high success with catching mafia and work really well together.  The problem is, up until we actually yeet mafia, it's kind of a "I'm going to treat you as town until I think I shouldn't."  Except the first game we ever played together, mafia!Chris has shot me N1 or N2. 

nows the time to think you shouldnt

5 minutes ago, Darthe said:

i think he is l-1.  dont vote yet just to be safe

I think he's at L-2, but I might have counted wrong.  I think I have Darthe, Hallia, Cory, and SD there right now unless I missed a vote.  I'm also super not used to this voting mechanic.  95% of the games I've played are deadline.

Unofficial Vote Count

 

Clov (4) - Darthe, Hallia, Cory, SinisterDeath

SD (3) - Verbal, Leelou, Clov

Leelou (1) - WhiskeyDelta

 

Not Voting (2) - Tripped, VooDoo

 

6 votes to hammer. 

 

COUNTDOWN LINK

28 minutes ago, Darthe said:

Darthe-esque paranoia post:
 

  Reveal hidden contents

Really, no need to read this.  

  Reveal hidden contents

I recognize that we lose this game if AJs a wolf, and I accept that.  Don't think the thought hasn't crossed my mind, I just think it's like 80/20 clov over him, and I don't wanna detract from that.  

 

 

Sometimes I wish I played as good as you guys have in your heads lol

9 minutes ago, Darthe said:

nows the time to think you shouldnt

Scratch this. I don’t want to bully you into your votes.  But I do need to stop flipflopping on your slot. Who’s your top wolf pick?