i figure that this thread has been done before but it popped into my head the first time i finished reading the series and it still bugs me today...

 

 

What are Osan'gar and Aran'gar up to? you hear about all of the Forsaken and all but raley about Osan'gar and Aran'gar....

 

 

just a thought...

One of them was Dashiva and I cant remember if he died at Shadar Logoth or escaped. The other has been posing as Halima, and her and Delanna slinked away from the reb Aesedai camp in the last book. As i can never keep the two straight, I prefer that one that is Halima, because shes/hes sexy.

Osan'gar died at SL, and I kinda doubt the DO would bring him back a second time. Would send the wrong signal to let someone get away with two major screw-ups.

I also prefer whichever one is Halima. Much more interesting disguise :P

DO NOT UNDER ANY CURCOMSTANCES READ THIS POST IF YOU HAVE NOT READ THROUGH WINTER'S HEART, OR DO NOT WANT TO KNOW THE EXACT IDENTIFICATION OF OSAN'GAR AND ARAN'GAR

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

AGAIN DO NOT READ THIS IF YOU DON'T WANT TO KNOW

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

LAST CHANCE NOT TO READ THIS

 

 

 

 

I've never quite understood why this is so difficult.

 

Agnior becomes Osan'gar poses as Deshiva dies at SL

 

Balthamel becomes Aran'gar poses as Halima.

 

Edit: oh, yeah, and I pick Aran'gar because a)she's hot, and b) she succeeds to a greater extent then Osan'gar, and really more then a lot of the other Forsaken. I was saddened when she was finally found out.

cool cool, that was easy to clear up...

 

 

 

but it brings up two other questions,

 

 

Where is Halima now and...

 

 

wasn't there a third person who was brought back from the dead or is my memory betraying me again?

I think that Aran'gar probably ran to Messana, since she's the closest to her. Though I don't know if she would have gone to another Forsaken after failing. I don't know. I don't think she would have had much of a chose to do otherwise.

 

There were two more reborn Forsaken

 

***SPOILERS FOR THOSE WHO DON'T WANT TO KNOW!!!***

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ishameal became Moridin

 

Lanfear became Cyndane

I've never quite understood why this is so difficult.

It isn't exactly difficult, just hard to remember which is which. Their names sound alike, ok? :P

I am going to mention them too, so spoiler spoiler spoiler.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I have to admit I use the rule: There's an o in Aginor and Osan'gar, and an a in Balthamel and Aran'gar. As to the question, I suppose I prefer Aran'gar. Balthamel died better, and now he/she's sexy. (Mustn't let Graendal know I think so, though)

there seems to be a bit of conflict of opinion in this area, unless i'm just not paying any attention...

cyndane is lanfear, but has that benn proved beyond a shadow of a doubt yet? has anyone come out and said that lanfear is cyndane? i know that women forsaken report that she is not as strong as lanfear was.

Her thoughts at the cleansing indicate Cyndane is Lanfear, there's no one else she could be. Eg, she was prepared to challenge the DO with Lews Therin.

Well it looks like Im the only one who prefers Osan'gar.......... nevermind..........

I just liked Dashiva!!! his part made me chuckle!!

i think aran'gar has been more effective in causing chaos, at least as far as we know. Unless someone can actually attribute the dissent in the black tower to osan'gar then he really didnt do much, my thoughts aer that he managed to turn Taim to the dark, otherwise i cant work out why Taim would have given Rand the seal, but thats just a theory