17 minutes ago, Verbal32 said:

 

I have zero experience with you, so I'm inclined to think you mixed me up with somebody else's post.

I did a quick look through of ALL the pages just looking for posts from you and I could not find anything about me so I have mixed you up yet again with another player. My sincere apologies Sir Verbal!

 

However, is it at all possible when you made the post about the possible scum and left a spot open with ??? it was because you know who the 3 are and didn't want to out your teammates? At least maybe you outed one for continuity but added a townie and left ??? for the third? Just asking 😇

51 minutes ago, Cairos said:

@Turin Turambar you picking me out again because i haven't posted that much and that RL stuff comes first. Also i'm not that great at playing mafia and i don't really know how to read people. I want to get better at playing mafia, that's why i'm joining. All i'm saying is that its hard to feel people out on day 1. All i see between some people are bantering which is fine. I don't mind the bantering. Some of that can be suss and can get rub people the wrong way. 

 

I'll be honest this posts kinda feels Villagery to me might be the first true post of Cairos between last game and this that really has.  Not super like solvey obviously but feels more sincere and genuine which I tend to feel comes from a Villager more often than not 

8 hours ago, Cairos said:

 

@ReleaseTheEvilYes i am sorry that i'm away from playing this game. Currently i am at work in the ER just trying to catch up on the game. It's not scummy that RL stuff comes first and then DM/WT/Mafia. Everybody has RL stuff thats more important. I also work the graveyard shift so working 7pm-7am. I'm at least trying to check in. 

Sure but that doesn't make you town. 

 

Also I didn't tag you in my post, how did you suddenly get to my post among everything you had to catch up with and address it so quickly? Did someone on your team tell you about it and signpost you to it? 

47 minutes ago, Gudrean said:

my current top 3 would lynch:

RTE

Lenlo

Verbal

 

Not necessarily in that order

 

 

Good God please be a villager and not just pocketing and owning my dumbass self lololololol 

5 hours ago, dicetosser1 said:

 

Reasons for Turin and me?

 

 

FTFY

Process of elimination. I think one of the three of you at minimum is scum. Of the three I think you're most likely the town player though

36 minutes ago, Cass said:

 

Are you up-to-date with the thread? And if so, any other vibes/thoughts, Gud?

Yes Ma'am I am.  Don't have any evidence but not sold on a Verbal town yet. Time will tell

and even tho I don't want Cairos to be wolf I am not sold on his township just yet.

I might also be letting the exciting posts of z/L make my judgements of Lenlo fuzzy. 

1 minute ago, Zander? said:

 

Good God please be a villager and not just pocketing and owning my dumbass self lololololol 

Feel it, know it, believe it! I am all Gud. 😊

41 minutes ago, Cass said:

 

a) You promised to try and learn!

b) Where/what is the 'super obvious' part you're referring to??

 

I am trying!!!!!!  I haven't tunneled or even pushed you atp. I just saw you in thread and let you know I need more to help keep my paranoia at bay as long as possible lol

 

Also you posted it and I gotta look for it?!?!??  You do realize right that some dumb annoying idiot jerk face has like 1000000 useless posts this game I gotta wade thru to find it right?!?!?!.......

 

*Backs away from thread slowly*

43 minutes ago, Verbal32 said:

Also, did Shad just hop into Zander's pocket?

 

I'm Zander Catchem Pokemon Trainer....and I gotta collect y'all and give them to my Pocket holding master Gud lololololol 

1 minute ago, Zander? said:

 

I'm Zander Catchem Pokemon Trainer....and I gotta collect y'all and give them to my Pocket holding master Gud lololololol 

 

9 minutes ago, ReleaseTheEvil said:

Sure but that doesn't make you town. 

 

Also I didn't tag you in my post, how did you suddenly get to my post among everything you had to catch up with and address it so quickly? Did someone on your team tell you about it and signpost you to it? 

I was at work and had some downtime to read and catch up. Even though it was busy, I had time to read. Why being so defensive?

6 minutes ago, ReleaseTheEvil said:

Process of elimination. I think one of the three of you at minimum is scum. Of the three I think you're most likely the town player though

Can you explain your process? How you selected your groups of three? That feels an odd way to state that.

Something feels very insincere about the people being too nice and trusting of each other. Feels like it is rubbing me the wrong way. The falling over themselves to try to clear each other and trust each other to the death sorta deal. 

Just now, Cairos said:

I was at work and had some downtime to read and catch up. Even though it was busy, I had time to read. Why being so defensive?

Cause when I mentioned you it felt like you had not posted in about 15 pages and then suddenly poof you magically appear to respond to only my claim, which I might add mentioned almost everyone in the game and didn't single you out. 

1 hour ago, Cass said:

FWIW current T-Z exchange looks ~good - glad I'm seeing it now and not still holding my breath on it from 17 pages ago if this is the first time you two have readdressed it... 

 

@Turin Turambar - Will the reason you asked besides asking Z be obvious by the time I'm caught up? You mention AI - if it's not that can you pls explain?

 

Sorry misread and misremembered apparently @Cass the Bold is what I was referencing but I must just saw obvious and Zander and assumer Super Obvious lololololol I 

1 minute ago, Turin Turambar said:

Can you explain your process? How you selected your groups of three? That feels an odd way to state that.

That's a good question.

 

Your group is old timers experienced folk. 

 

Other group is newer blood/less experienced in Mafia. 

 

Based on probabilities and the fact I'm not so sure about the 6 of you, I think at least two of you are scum. 

47 minutes ago, Verbal32 said:

 

Can I assume you're joking about a "D1 pass"?  Please say you are.

 

Nope am not.  If I'm not sold on someone or feel decent enough and have others I feel worse I give them a D1 pass from me.  Can be revoked from later gameplay and the like or possibility of a No Lunch but I can't even recall the last time I had to do that tbqh.

2 minutes ago, ReleaseTheEvil said:

That's a good question.

 

Your group is old timers experienced folk. 

 

Other group is newer blood/less experienced in Mafia. 

 

Based on probabilities and the fact I'm not so sure about the 6 of you, I think at least two of you are scum. 

So, does that mean you have the rest of the players as town? If you had to guess one of them was actually mafia, who would you pick and why?

2 minutes ago, Zander? said:

 

Nope am not.  If I'm not sold on someone or feel decent enough and have others I feel worse I give them a D1 pass from me.  Can be revoked from later gameplay and the like or possibility of a No Lunch but I can't even recall the last time I had to do that tbqh.

To be fair this isn't such an outlandish idea.  D1 Lynch is so much guesswork anyways. May be worth giving someone the benefit of the doubt for it. 

50 minutes ago, Verbal32 said:

Because if you're town and Shad isn't, he just pocketed you and you just basically explained why above.

 

Only for today homie if it's that exact scenario.  I've done ok enough reading Shad historically just takes a couple phases lolololol.   D1 is EBOLAIDS as you know.  I need flips, Wagonomics, spew etc to really start making sense of it all.  I always take that going into D2. ( Providing in still alive lol). And reevaluate if necessary.

1 minute ago, Turin Turambar said:

So, does that mean you have the rest of the players as town? If you had to guess one of them was actually mafia, who would you pick and why?

Sorry of whom are we speaking? I covered it when I named everyone. 

 

Also very real chance the 3 scum are among the 6 of you anyways, so bit moot point 

Zander why have you not commented on my list? Mr oh no the game is so quiet. Of all the things not to mention... 

52 minutes ago, Turin Turambar said:

That would  be pocketception. 

 

I exist on a much high plane of Villagery frequency and have skills only the most Majestic, Holy Pure Villagers can obtain lol

2 minutes ago, ReleaseTheEvil said:

Sorry of whom are we speaking? I covered it when I named everyone. 

 

Also very real chance the 3 scum are among the 6 of you anyways, so bit moot point 

Well you put 6 people out in two groups and stated you thought there were at least 2 mafia in the 6. There are 11 people in the game. If you have your mafia group exclusive in those 6, do you think the remaining 5 players are town? Or are they null? And then of those 5 which do you think might still be mafia?

 

44 minutes ago, Cass said:

 

# relatable XD

 

But no, no D1 pass for Shad on that ever again, because +/- tinfoil for those last two games where that was definitely a trap

 

I'll give him it.  Because a) IM NOT AFRAID and b) I know how good Town!Shad is I'm I don't like chancing D1 EBOLAIDS on him unless there's a pretty high level of him being a Wolf like  more than the roughly little better than 1/3 chance for this game setup with 11 players and 3 Wolves from OP