Now, I am of the group who thinks you are innocent.

But that little comment with the wink made you seem less so...Just a little.

Ah whatever man.

 

I've been telling the truth all along - if I'm gonna find us some more scum, I'm gonna need protection during the night, or else I'm toast.

I know...I still believe you are innocent.

I was just saying.

 

Do we even have a healer/guardian in this game?

Are they standard in each game?

Cause unless the healer/guardian is one of those people who haven't been really following along, I think that they have already heard your case (through Pete and then by your own mouth {fingers, cause you typed it!})

I think somebody suggested Boopsy and Rey, but I don't really see where their behavior was out of the ordinary, which means absolutely nothing, of course. The reason my Kivam gambit failed was that we were too obvious....lol. But then, we're both "in your face" people, and anything else would have looked odd.

 

Okay, enough metagaming for me. Personally, I find it helpful, but others don't.

 

 

 

I just had the reason bout him saying lots of mafia is good.. But thats not necessarily a solid ground :P

 

Now, I am of the group who thinks you are innocent.

But that little comment with the wink made you seem less so...Just a little.

 

It does seem a bit defensive doesnt it?? But he's been defensive the whole time so far..

 

*ponders*

 

*EDIT*

 

We dont really know Ed since she modified all the roles.. But i think she probably has.. My tip is on Carslile being Healetr

 

Lol I think I have reason to act "defensive". I was 100% that Boopsy was Mafia and he was still fighting to make me look suspicious. Now that ive been proved right there are still doubts floating around - people what more can I do?!

Yeah, I think there must be a healer of some type in the game. Otherwise any of us who reveal will just get bumped off.

Just let the matter stand as is.

You have proved yourself (mostly), don't bring it up unless someone else does.

then just point out that you were right....

That is what I would do if I were you.

 

Car guy would be a good choice for healer, since we pretty much know that the Cullens are innocent (two have died and were shown innocent).

 

EDIT NEW: True...I guess all games would have at least one huh?

Yeah most games would.

 

Car guy? I've not seen or read any of the books or films, so can someone explain this?

The 'dad'...

Carslile....Tynaal posted it...

I don't know how to spell his name, so I am assuming this is it...

lol...he is a doctor in the movie/book.

That would fit. Another name for the healer role is doctor, just like the finder can also be called the cop.

 

 

In this game, is it more likely that the Chief Swan role is the moderator's, or is it actually one of us?

 

Just asking out of curiosity, and wanting to understand a little better

 

 

Hmm it would fit..

 

But I dunno if she (min) can "play" him if he's a role

Min has added a lot of twists to this game, and anything's possible, but I'd guess he's the finder/cop.

 

 

I think he's probably a role, too. Usually anyone mentioned in the OP is a role in the game. I don't think the mod ever has a role.

nah i think that if he is in the game, then a player has him.  would be unfair for him to have a role and be played by the mod.  cause the mod knows who and what everyone is. 

 

btw ....

 

 

lmao

LOL love it!

Sorry what I meant to ask was, is Chief Swan just a narrator.  Even though I asked poorly, thanks for the great answers. :)

Red I love that picture!!! Oh, and I love the speculations. Keep them up I am having way to much fun. Now I see why Pete loves to Mod so much.

She didn't even answer! :'(

 

Lol...Red, the picture was hilarious!

 

It seems like he is a player in the game, but Min just uses him to narrate when she needs to.

I love that picture Red.

 

And I am not so sure about chief swan, he may be a player in the game, there is no reason for him not to be, but if Min keeps using him she is reaffirming his innocence with every post. Taking into account a game this large I am figuring in a cult, there is just about to many players for there not to be. So chief swan could get recruited into the cult and he can reveal and be free from suspicion.

 

Everyone needs to take everything into account, and do not free anyone from suspicion, even if they are an outed healer, or finder or whatever.

I'm looking forward to actually seeing you in action in a game I'm in, Pete.

Unless you are a LLL, mafia, or cult.

What is an LLL?

 

And, did you just ignore Wombat?  :-\

 

So, does the Mod know who is cultified? Would she still use him if he was a player and we had a cult in this game that 'recruited' him?

This game is making me laugh; Pete's head is going to be huge! :P

 

I just want to say that even though as an innocent Pete usually does a good job, he's not infallible and I've seen him completely tear apart someone who was honestly and completely innocent; twisting words and misinterpreting them to say that the person had contradicted herself...  He was innocent too, but he was tearing into all the wrong people.  He's a great player, and an excellent Mod, but if you end up trusting his innocence, don't take everything he says as doctrine.

 

My main point is not in reality a stab at Pete at all, because I admire him when it comes to mafia  :D, but rather a lesson to you Noobs--it can seem natural to just follow along with the experienced players who have a huge reputation, and it can seem natural to hold them in awe and treat them as godlike.  Don't.  They're just people too, and while a lot that they say can be helpful and beneficial, they're still perfectly capable of making mistakes--so if you have a gut feeling that they're wrong, don't quell it, go along with it and feel free to challenge that big scary famous mafia player.  You're just as important to the game as they are. ;)

 

**EDIT NEW**

I can't for the life of me figure out what LLL means, Pete. O.o

Lying liar who lies