actually I got an idea go back and look who was pushing for the Nya lynch

actually I got an idea go back and look who was pushing for the Nya lynch

 

I did, because I thought her half claim a product of panic and would make her a target anyway. I recall not being the only one with that line of thinking, including Ithi who flipped town. Now that I think about it, Darthe did something very similar, which puts him near the top of my list of suspects with Wombat

actually I got an idea go back and look who was pushing for the Nya lynch

 

I did, because I thought her half claim a product of panic and would make her a target anyway. I recall not being the only one with that line of thinking, including Ithi who flipped town. Now that I think about it, Darthe did something very similar, which puts him near the top of my list of suspects with Wombat

 

Darthe did something like a flipped Townie so we should FOS him? I think you need a little more elaboration here

I think he saw it work once and decided to try it again, except with a little more finesse than Nya freaking out. It was a but of an unformed thought, I should clarify this is in conjunction with other cases on him

*bit

EP, I would like you to quote where I said I trusted you, because I don't recall saying any such thing. Furthermore, just because I was leaning town on you does not mean I thought your reads were correct.

then that was me misreading your whole "leaning town" comment givde me a good target for the lynch today one I think legit and I'll move my vote, I don't like the fact we've yet to find a single mafia, I'm likening to the idea of Len and Darthe but I want to see a better case on them also who pushed the Nya thing after day 1 is an important thing as well.

Vote Count

Wombat (3) -- Firebird, BG, Roo,

Nol (1) -- Smiles

 

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch

 

Countdown

 

Vote Count

Wombat (3) -- Firebird, Wombat, Roo,

Nol (1) -- Smiles

 

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch

 

Countdown

 

*poke* My vote?

<.< >.> No clue what you're talking about *fix*

I hate my life. I'm the worst Cop ever. Lynching me would be lynching a vanilla at this point.

 

Whoever is sending in kills thinks like I do cause I viewed Nyan.

 

I'm going to give EP the benefit of the doubt and trust him that he is a redirector right now and assume town because I've gotta trust something.

 

Vote Wombat cause he's the one that always seems to be able to predict my NA's in all the games I've been in.

why did you view Nyan over someone else?

I had been suspicious over Nyan on previous days and I wanted to avoid viewing whoever EP switched.

can you be more specific?

*Throws popcorn at the silent people*

I have jus t done a retread and EP Tina Thorum and Nolder ping me most in the first 40 pages. I think out of the set we can find at lest two scum. EP, notably, has been pinged by EVERY person that has died in the game and both Tina and Thorum act oddly but seem at ends with each other. It is either clever distancing or they one is scum and not the other. I'll post more when I catch up

I think I have been pinged by every active member still alive too so point invalid sir.

Haha fail. "most think I'm scum so I must not be scum.". That's really your case? Vote EP

Can't red or bold on my phone :/

Vote: Darthe. As I stated earlier, I don't like how he dropped a hint to a role and people backed off of him without pressing him on what his role is. I can't think of too much else out there that's not been claimed so far, so either he's pulling an Arez and is trying to draw attention to himself, or he's scum, doesn't have a role and wanted to survive another day.

Once more I am forced to question your logic Razen. There are dozens of mafia roles and only three or four have been claimed in this entire game. Weak reasoning is weak. The truth of it is, all of the town should have been concerned by three potentially key players revealing in one night. We haven't done well at all in this game and some direction has to happen. Unless there is a good cause, transparency with the town is the best decision to be made. It doesn't leave scum anywhere to hide and limits their opportunity to manipulate the situation as you are currently doing. The town can judge me on my words as they wish. Start killing scum and stop lynching scum hunters. My vote stands.

Darthe you aren't winning anyone over with that piss poor logic just thought you should know, oh and for lols I had a PR day one that said I was to try my very best not to get lynched the other reason for all my Psyduckery on day 1. I figured if I just ducked around people would get a giggle and not want to lynch me. I am a town bus driver so there is no reason to lynch me. especially now that we lost our doc the mafia have a 50/50 chance of killing a power role if you don't take in the scemantics of my role so basically more of a 50/50 chance of guessing right atm you can't afford to lynch me. I am the only protection BG has left, if I were to be lynched this day Darthe BG dies if I am not lynched the mafia are going to have a really tough time figuring out which of us is the safe target I already know which mafioso I'll be targeting.

Once more I am forced to question your logic Razen. There are dozens of mafia roles and only three or four have been claimed in this entire game. Weak reasoning is weak. The truth of it is, all of the town should have been concerned by three potentially key players revealing in one night. We haven't done well at all in this game and some direction has to happen. Unless there is a good cause, transparency with the town is the best decision to be made. It doesn't leave scum anywhere to hide and limits their opportunity to manipulate the situation as you are currently doing. The town can judge me on my words as they wish. Start killing scum and stop lynching scum hunters. My vote stands.

 

You aren't scum hunting at all. You're trying to find out who you can night kill without getting protected by the Doc and getting around EP's switch. And if you claim that transparent play as the town is best, then why did you drop a hint at all? You've just contradicted your own play with that sentence right there. My vote stands.

 

I have jus t done a retread and EP Tina Thorum and Nolder ping me most in the first 40 pages. I think out of the set we can find at lest two scum. EP, notably, has been pinged by EVERY person that has died in the game and both Tina and Thorum act oddly but seem at ends with each other. It is either clever distancing or they one is scum and not the other. I'll post more when I catch up

 

Is this supposed to be scumhunting? Because it's not. Tina and Thorum aren't even playing anymore - they've been replaced. Your case against EP is nothing more than OMGUS, and you provide no reasoning as to why you think Nolder is scum. Let's go back to night 2:

 

I never noticed this before:

we have just lined ourselves up rather nicely for the mafia to shoot us though >.<

 

You mean like we are going to tonight? Or cop. Can you redirect from cop and area protect himself?

 

SCUM SLIP!!!!

 

This isn’t even what I was looking for, and I noticed it trying to find out where Darthe had been questioning EP where his targets were.

 

and asking us our targets at night is like asking us "hey who are you not going to protect"

 

This. I agree with this statement.

 

How could I fish out anything from you all? There is nothing left to fish, you have admitted to your roles. Dude we have had seven games together now and you think I'm scum from day 1 in all of em :p 2/7 is an awful meta.

 

This is Darthe’s response to EP’s accusation that Darthe was rolefishing. He says that since the town players outed most of the power roles that there’s nothing left to fish? Why does that mean that everyone gets to know the targets? It makes it way too easy for you to pick someone that’s not targeted.

On and that was in response the the message where you said he outed himself, not the shooting us thing.

 

I suppose that would be a viable thing to call a scum slip if it was me replying to EP's post at the time, however if you had read you would notice the time signatures place me as typing that before he got his message up. Not here how I said it was in reaponse to a previous comment. Keep digging that grave Razen. And did you not just vote me for trying to influence the role claims and gaming, then attempt to get me to role claim? It's rhetorical, you did.

The time signatures:

 

Eternal Phoenix, on 30 May 2012 - 10:20 AM, said:

 

we have just lined ourselves up rather nicely for the mafia to shoot us though >.<

 

 

Darthe, on 30 May 2012 - 10:22 AM, said:

 

You mean like we are going to tonight? Or cop. Can you redirect from cop and area protect himself?

 

That is not posting before EP. Unless you come from the future, which I highly doubt.

Well stated arguements Razen.

 

Unvote: Vote Darthe.

 

The only reason I unvoted Darthe really yesterday was because Wombat said he "strongly suggests" we don't vote Darthe and then I moved for consensous.