Jump to content

A Game of Thrones - Mafia by Darthe and Ithillian - Game Over, Mafia Wins!

Featured Replies

  • Replies 2.3k
  • Views 81.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Author

The morning had been tense for all. A lords son was dead and the chief adviser to another had been beheaded on a whim. The Iron Throne loomed like a tombstone in its otherwise barren chamber. The light of a young morning shone in through the stained glass windows of the Throne Room and cast the shadows of just two seats, one ornate and one simple. Outside the castle walls a plume of dust and the sound of clopping hoofs hinted at passage being granted. City life, for the most part, carried on oblivious to the wars being waged behind the walls of the castle at King's Landing. Wars carried on the swords of wagging tongues and jabs sent through the air with a glare rather than a strong cavalryman's arm, but wars nonetheless. Of the bodies left from the events of the night and day before, their was no sign, but the silent sisters traveled in safety back to the cold abode of Winterfell's Crypts to carry Robb Stark with all due honor. A storm brewed overhead down the Kingsroad. Cold grey eyes watched it with only one certainty. Winter was coming.

  • Author

Official Vote Count:

 

Despo (3): EP, Mynd, BG

 

EP (4): Despo, Andrew, Blackhoof

 

Kudaran Dragon Blooded (1): TinaHel

 

Mynd (2): Arez, Peace

 

Tina (1): Razen

 

Not voting (10): Alanna, Jack, Kae, Kudaran, Len, Rand, Tinker, TMD, Tress, Turin

 

 

 

Here is a countdown timer until night:

 

http://www.timeandda...0=745&msg=Night

Alright finally got a breather at work. Tbh, I was hoping we'd be a little further in the scumhunt after logging off this morning, but I see once again the scumhunting has been stalled due to theme-focused spam. I swear, when I finally make my own mafia game I'm going to use the most obscure story ever so nobody knows enough to blab about it all the time :rolleyes:

 

Also, some of the game setup talk is worrying me. While it does seem like this game might have slightly diff mechanics, it's still a little early to be speculating too much about it, and it also gives scum a good opportunity to try and breadcrumb some kind of weird concept which then becomes more believable when they try claiming it to be true.

 

I'm bout to start audit, but once I finish I'm gonna come back and go through the last few pages and see if there was some slip that scum might have tried to bury with spam, or some setup talk that seems to be "setting up" a mafia gambit

Official Vote Count:

 

Despo (3): EP, Mynd, BG

 

EP (4): Despo, Andrew, Blackhoof

 

Kudaran Dragon Blooded (1): TinaHel

 

Mynd (2): Arez, Peace

 

Tina (1): Razen

 

Not voting (10): Alanna, Jack, Kae, Kudaran, Len, Rand, Tinker, TMD, Tress, Turin

 

 

 

Here is a countdown timer until night:

 

http://www.timeandda...0=745&msg=Night

 

EP has 4 votes?

I'll post my thoughts a bit later this weekend I need to work on my WT event atm and I'm currently in the middle of a move from 4th floor to the first floor in my building soooo I'll be scarce during the weekends

Good morning GoT Mafia Fans.

 

I know you will not be so busy over the weekend and it's cool. The Timer will keep ticking down in the meantime however.

 

I'm going out and about myself today so will be a little scarse - I will be keep an ever watchful eye on all that occurs here though.

 

:smile:

Hodor

so the one post with words was just a mistake? I see it appears your double vote is in place. Logic says just an oops moment and the mods were merciful.

 

Hodor

 

Hodor

 

Hodor

 

 

Exactly why I said before twice I think that we shouldn't put trust in character claims and instead focus on gameplay.

 

^hodor

 

Alright finally got a breather at work. Tbh, I was hoping we'd be a little further in the scumhunt after logging off this morning, but I see once again the scumhunting has been stalled due to theme-focused spam. I swear, when I finally make my own mafia game I'm going to use the most obscure story ever so nobody knows enough to blab about it all the time :rolleyes:

 

Also, some of the game setup talk is worrying me. While it does seem like this game might have slightly diff mechanics, it's still a little early to be speculating too much about it, and it also gives scum a good opportunity to try and breadcrumb some kind of weird concept which then becomes more believable when they try claiming it to be true.

 

I'm bout to start audit, but once I finish I'm gonna come back and go through the last few pages and see if there was some slip that scum might have tried to bury with spam, or some setup talk that seems to be "setting up" a mafia gambit

 

^hodor

 

 

Hodor!

vote EP

 

 

 

Hodor!

 

Not to question the insightful musings of one of Winterfell's great philosophers, but Hodor is trying to lynch his own Lord Stark, my father. While I think we can agree that character claiming is not a basis for alignment in this game, one would have a hard time convincing me that Ned Stark is anything but Town.

 

Hodor!

What?! Take back what you said about my mother!!! How dare you!

 

Alright finally got a breather at work. Tbh, I was hoping we'd be a little further in the scumhunt after logging off this morning, but I see once again the scumhunting has been stalled due to theme-focused spam. I swear, when I finally make my own mafia game I'm going to use the most obscure story ever so nobody knows enough to blab about it all the time :rolleyes:

Spam is a mafia tactic. Don't let anyone convince you otherwise. Someone wants some of the stuff we discussed buried. This is mafia, no tea party.

 

Also, some of the game setup talk is worrying me. While it does seem like this game might have slightly diff mechanics, it's still a little early to be speculating too much about it, and it also gives scum a good opportunity to try and breadcrumb some kind of weird concept which then becomes more believable when they try claiming it to be true.

Wait, WHAT?! It's never too early to speculate on how the game is set up. In order to properly scum-hunt, you gotta know what a scum looks and smells like first. You wouldn't hunt a bear with duck shot would you? What bothers me about your statement is that it strikes me as one who was depending on our assumption of a standard mafia game to run his gambit but now we've figured out the portion of the game you wanted us to be blind to.

 

I'm bout to start audit, but once I finish I'm gonna come back and go through the last few pages and see if there was some slip that scum might have tried to bury with spam, or some setup talk that seems to be "setting up" a mafia gambit

Good luck! Enjoy sifting through all that spam to find a reason to switch your vote off EP without looking scummy.

  • Author

By the way, your PR is over Mynd. By all means, keep posting and adding stuff as it is amusing but you do not have to anymore.

Jack, to answer your question I am guessing based on the number of claimed roles do far and the coroner reports of the dead that this game is primarily roled. I am pretty sure there are still some vanillas out there tho

 

I have a question for some of the fans out there. How far into the story was it that king Robert died? And the same for eddard? The wiki gives dates but in a book storyline is not always in step with time. I get the impression both events happen fairly early.

Ned died near the end as that is what caused Robb to rise up and become king of the North, which ended the first book. Baratheon was very early on.

Depends on when we start. This is the order of people sitting on throne.

 

For those of you who dont like spoilers. Its only the order of kings in the books.

 

 

 

Robert ---> Joffery --->(Ned dies) ---------------------------> (Still Joffery, lots of other people claiming the throne)

V

Robb becomes king in the North -> (Robb dies) -> Bran becomes King in the North.

 

We still have the two Baratheons and the Greyjoys though as wll.

 

 

 

F UUUUUUUUUUUuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu... HUGE SPOILER IN THERE DO NOT CLICK.

 

 

RGHRNJUGNR.

 

Before every spoiler can we please put in big block bold capitals something like "IF YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT HAPPENS PAST SEASON 2 PLEASE DO NOT CLICK"

 

:sad:

here is all the stuff I multiquoted while writing my scenes, I only got a couple minutes to slack off before I need to move a couple more things then go pass out

 

I'm addressing different points in color cause I'm feeling frisky this morning.

 

In this game with apparently a silent voter, deputy, a deputies deputy, every other night role cop, double voter with a pr condition (a la EP) I'm inclined to believe no one is "vanilla"

 

Although EP initially claimed vanilla so idk. So I'm a little timid atm

 

I claimed I was temp vanilla night 1 as my role was stolen for the phase, however as they used my ability I cannot use it this night, I have a suspicion that will be a re-occuring issue, Jack you are looking for a role thief, they will keep stealing from me to make me look suspicious.

 

Also I don't like Despo continually mentioning how it could be a "bastard Mod" move etc. etc. That just gives the impression that either you are right or this game is totally unfair which I think IS tunnel-vision when you don't know all the possible roles out there. It feels a tidbit manipulative to try and use this as an arguement.

 

Agreed. And even though it seems unlikely that everything should happen at ones with EP it might be truth. Not saying it is, but it could be. In Lily´s game we had random events happen every day and I happened to be targeted by three of five.

 

I'm interested in finding out people's oppinions on weather this is a mostly roled game or mostly nila

 

Please and thank you.

 

Well, to answer that you pretty much give away if you are roled or not.

 

He already revealed he was a role cop..

 

The whole claiming it as bastard modding is a nice little ploy to cast doubt on the person being argued against

 

Why are we voting Ned Stark? Say what you want about the Firecrotch Witch being town, but the one character I would know to be town would be Ned Stark. Even if EP is making some of the stuff happening to him up, that doesn't make him scum. I find anyone voting EP after the

whole Throne mess to be highly questionable.

 

I like how Despo turned his attentions directly on EP to cast suspicion off him and Turin.

 

vote Despo

 

I got ninjad, and for the better.

 

It seems that EP and Mynd might be a team together.. He's been subtley defending EP forever. I'm very inclined to thing that they are either third party or scum~~~~

 

Well the town is a shoddy type of team, no real communication but 2 townies can still be considered on a team together, soooo logic fail

 

Blablabla, I only know one of your tactics Mynd, and I would be STUPID to use it against you.

 

Stop crying Mynd. I'm not with Despo, but he's made more sense than EP has.

 

I find it curious how you encourage scum hunting, but when you end up being examined, THE ONE DOING IT IS SCUM!!!!

No Mynd, you're not intimidating me away from you by threats.

 

except you completely make no sense *shrug*

 

Jack, asking who is roled and who is not is scummy. It creates a pool of targets for NK's.

 

FOS Jack.

 

Also narrows down my targets for viewing. With an every other night power I'd rather not waste it

 

but you did not ask who was roled you asked if people thought it was full of roles or possibly alot of vanilla

 

A true Game of Thrones would be to have all town players, in keeping with how everyone sees themselves as town, and each of them competing for the Iron Throne. Does anyone have a win condition that is similar to "when all threats to your crown are eliminated' or "all threats to your claim to the throne" are eliminated?

 

Mynd just made a major scum slip.

 

The fact that he asked this question means he does not have a "town" win condition. If he did..then his point would be moot and there would not be a full game of competing factions. My win condition states I win with town. Therefore his theory is bogus and he is scum

 

VOTE MYND.

 

If you are not a potential heir to the throne, then of course your win condition would be normal, as is mine. If you were a Stannis, Danerys, Joffrey, or Ned, perhaps your win condition is different but still town. I am not an heir to the throne and I win with the town, but those who are might have a different win condition.

 

What I think is going on in this game is that everyone is town, but the heirs to the throne have a unique win condition about eliminating other threats to the throne.

 

Tbh I didn't really get this, I've never seen a setup like this

 

A) I think Mynd has a point about steering clear of claimed Ned Stark

 

B) I think there is a specific person who holds the Iron Throne that is given extra abilities

 

C) I think certain players have ambitions to claim the Throne

 

D) I think there are others that serve the throne loyally with no ambition to become King.

 

E) I believe it is my duty, and the duty of the town, to protect the King.

 

B) ummm what makes you believe this?

 

C) possible, but I'm not sure how this would come into play

 

D) you say throne, but not king, why?

 

E) now you say king, but capitalizing the K, who do you think holds the Iron Throne based on your assumptions? as in character?

 

I'm glad we are on the same page Mynd. I suppose the Starks don't count as people who are trying to claim the Iron Throne since none of them have wanted it. Not Ned. Not Robb. He's King in the North, but not Iron Throne King. I also think the current King spoke to us directly yesterday with all that Hash Browns talk.

 

again, why do you feel this to be the case?

 

I would be disappointed if Tyrion wasnt in this. He is the best imp ever.

 

except Turin claimed Tyrion's body guard, oh how I love skimmers they make the game easy,

 

 

ok out of that wot, I'd like to hear some thoughts from BG, not that I specifically suspect you BG, but why do you feel the way you do?

 

beginning to see who might be against town here,

 

Despo

Lenlo

Andrew

Tress

 

my top choices right now

Yes EP, because my expressing an opinion on a favorite character, is skimmy and scummy. I never said he wasnt in the game just that I would be disappointed if he wasnt. Looks like your trying to latch onto anything that you can right now.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.