I didn't find this anywhere on this site and I always wanted to see this.

 

GO!

Haha this would be awesome, Aes Sedai wins. She can use air, water, fire, earth, and spirit, while Jedi can only use something like air.

Air/spirit. You are, however, forgetting one thing.

 

 

Lightsabers.

I thought about that.

 

But then I wondered how to fight this.

 

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Force_storm_%28wormhole%29

Balefire.

/thread.

Lightsaber! (does lightsaber block balefire like the sword that is not a sword?)

Lightsaber! (does lightsaber block balefire like the sword that is not a sword?)

 

Nope.

A lightsaber, may 'destroy' anything it touches, but it doesn't operate the same as balefire. It doesn't for instance.. Change Space and Time.

To put it simply, if used against palpatine using his force-storm, you could kill him, before he used it on yoru planet and thusly, it never went off! Course, that would probably cause you not to use balefire in the first place... but thats irrelevant, as he'd already be toast.

Of course they could always jump out of the way of balefire.

oh very good

Of course they could always jump out of the way of balefire.

 

Right back on top of it.

No but Jedi have special jumping skills, have you seen how far one jumps!

No but Jedi have special jumping skills, have you seen how far one jumps!

 

Would be truelly impressive in the Ways.

I wonder how the Jedi mind control would affect TAV. Or would the pattern bend the Jedi so that it always missed. Perhaps the Aes Sedai would trip on a rock and miss being spliced.

So... Rand Vs. Darthe? There is only one way to settle this! To the battlegrounds! =p

Don't spend your points and i will do it, after I get the turtle angreal. or actually I might get the snake, not right now though.

We talking one on one here, or a group of Jedi vs. a bunch of AS?

 

One on one, the Jedi has a good chance since most AS aren't very skilled in martial weaves, and even the most BA warder () wouldn't really be able to do much against a lightsaber-wielding Jedi knight.

 

But in a group, the AS would completely dominate. They can heal, and have far more variety of uses for their power. And since pretty much all AS have a rock hard will, the jedi mind trick wouldn't work so well.

 

Jedi: These are not the droids you're looking for... *waves hand mysteriously*

 

AS: *uses compulsion, gets Jedi to tell her the truth*

 

AS: *balefires Jedi and droids*

i got ninjad again!!! Flashfire i was wanting you to bring this here!

 

Id like to see an AS try to compulse Yoda!! Way NO!!!!!!!!!

 

the healing is the only advantage they have

Healing is a huge advantage in a group kind of scenario tho...

 

I agree, Yoda is uncompulsable.

Apart from AS are totally wet and can't usually tell their ar .... are not very good at being all battle-ish. That is why they have to have warders, cos they get so tired from whipping up a gentle breeze. Not many can actually do the Balefire after all.

 

Whereas a Jedi is like an AS and a Warder all rolled into one. How many AS would you see walk into a battlezone and cause the thousands of people there to want to run and hide because they know they will not survive the encounter?

Also, good AS are not allowed to use compulsion. It is a big no-no remember?

Apart from AS are totally wet and can't usually tell their ar .... are not very good at being all battle-ish. That is why they have to have warders, cos they get so tired from whipping up a gentle breeze. Not many can actually do the Balefire after all.

 

Whereas a Jedi is like an AS and a Warder all rolled into one. How many AS would you see walk into a battlezone and cause the thousands of people there to want to run and hide because they know they will not survive the encounter?

 

I agree with you on the whole inexperience in battle thing, which is why I included warders in the scenario (and even they would still not really have much of a shot at slowing the Jedi down)

 

But honestly, I'm not thinking of the current AS when I thought of the question. I was thinking of the classic interpretation of them, where they were much more powerful and knowledgeable in the One Power. After all, it's the same True Source they're dealing with, they just didn't suck like the Third Agers did.

 

And one other thing I think you're passing over. With multiple AS you get circles, and with combined power from multiple powerful AS you could easily BF the everloving dog stuff out of some Jedi. Or blow the crap out of them with fireballs, or ice storms, or any other kind of insane weave. And since they can heal each other, it becomes very difficult to really seize momentum from them.

 

Plus, if the Jedi get to have their lightsabers, then AS get to bring their angreal and ter'angreal

 

Also, good AS are not allowed to use compulsion. It is a big no-no remember?

 

Who said these were "good" AS we were talking about here? I was envisioning a scenario where an AS would be able to pull literally any trick with the OP out of their sleeve they wanted to. Weaves of Spirit to cause the Jedi to hallucinate, slice them open with a gateway, do that whole extremely thin crazy sharp and also invisible weave of Air to lop their heads off in one stroke. That kind of thing

Well, if you can change the parameters to whatever you want, then of course whatever you say is correct.

 

 

 

whatever you say is correct.

 

I'll change YOUR parameters

My parameters are firmly fixed.

 

I actually got a diff question. How do yall think the AS (AoL AS that is) would fare against a Mistborn?