Official Vote Count

 

Lily(2): Darthe, David

David (1): Len

Despo(1): Wombat

Mynd(1): Tress

Kat(1): Lily

 

 

 

Not Voting (16): Arez, Alanna, Andrew, Basel, Despo, Dice, John, Kathleen, Mynd, Nolder, Nyanna, Peace, Rand, Razen,Tiinker, Turin, Tress

 

With 21 alive and active it takes 11 to Lynch.

 

Deadline Friday @ Noon CT

 

http://www.timeandda...=Deadline&csz=1

Posting a dead player's thoughts about players seems outside the spirit of the game

 

Ageed

Meta-Knight looked... "You? No!" There was a bright flash....

 

So, EP is Meta-Knight... is Asmodean??!!

Meta-Knight looked... "You? No!" There was a bright flash....

 

So, EP is Meta-Knight... is Asmodean??!!

 

XD

Meta-Knight looked... "You? No!" There was a bright flash....

 

So, EP is Meta-Knight... is Asmodean??!!

 

!!!!!!

 

 

Basel gets +1 cool points

Still not sure what to think about Lily's reveal btw.

 

Lily, you said those were not your thoughts and everything, but what ARE your thoughts on the players he mentioned? You agree/disagree?

I would also like to heard what Lily thinks, before I make any vote decisions. 'Cause this seems like a bad plan whether she's Town or Mafia.

Well I'll see yall later, time for family time. I'll be on tonight

I'm a bit concerned that Wombat would come out so strongly against Arez and then vote someone else

 

Lily just did something similar and then voted her FoS which seems normal

 

Why didn't you vote Arez Wombat?

 

Because I after reading the pages after page 5 I changed my mind. You maf bro?

Yes Wombat, I am incredibly maf.

And he didn't flip as a mason.. And other stuffs.

 

This. If he had been a mason, that would have been in his flip.

 

Couldn't a player be both a mason and a power role?

 

But I do have a question for Lily, is EP even allowed to post on your "mason qt" after he died?

 

I would hazard the answer is a no, and the fact that you are saying you are posting EP's thoughts, when EP never talked about Nya or never outright told us he was suspicious of her, I think is just false. I really don't feel that dead players are allowed to continue posting game information, so I would feel that as a breach in my opinion.

 

So, vote LilyElizabeth.

 

Also this. If EP was so suspicious of Nya, then why hasn't he mentioned her on-thread? I'm figuring that EP's so-called thoughts have been invented by Lily, and she is making the mason claim up off the top of her head.

 

And he didn't flip as a mason.. And other stuffs.

So far, for the two roles we've seen, none have been standard names. So, it's not impossible to say that he was a mason with Lily.

 

Absorber is a pre-existing role. It has an entry on the MafiaScum wiki. It sounds standard to me. Or do you mean standard as in a "standard" game? This is an advanced game, BG said so back in the signups.

 

Vote Lily.

I have a town read on Lily fyi.

Also this. If EP was so suspicious of Nya, then why hasn't he mentioned her on-thread? I'm figuring that EP's so-called thoughts have been invented by Lily, and she is making the mason claim up off the top of her head.

 

Yushyush, this makes me wonder also.

Posting a dead player's thoughts about players seems outside the spirit of the game

 

Ageed

I fink so too

Couldn't a player be both a mason and a power role?

 

But I do have a question for Lily, is EP even allowed to post on your "mason qt" after he died?

 

I would hazard the answer is a no, and the fact that you are saying you are posting EP's thoughts, when EP never talked about Nya or never outright told us he was suspicious of her, I think is just false. I really don't feel that dead players are allowed to continue posting game information, so I would feel that as a breach in my opinion.

 

So, vote LilyElizabeth.

 

Yes, he is, but not game related thoughts. He posted that WoT on the QT during the night. It is normal policy for dead players to be allowed to continue to post on QTs, and I don't know why there is a restriction on this game, but that's what I was told by BG.

Like I'm pretty sure I've already said, I'm getting this game confused with another, and really need to find the time to reread. I don't have any thoughts of my own about the game at this time, except that I actually wouldn't mind dying, because I could keep one game straight. But that's not fair to the town, to just give up, so I'll do that reread and figure something out. In other words, I'll have to get back to y'all with my thoughts.

I believe Lily when she says that she was posting EP's thoughts. It's not unheard of for dead players to still communicate (I'm thinking about the DPR Dark Monocle game in particular) and get their thoughts posted on the thread by someone who could read the QT or a teammate. And I don't get why she'd stick EP's name in there and say she was his teammate if it wasn't true. So this reaching to discredit her based on something trivial like the role flip of EP is ridiculous. Just because it doesn't say mason doesn't mean that he couldn't communicate. And to be honest, I'm beginning to get a scum read on those that are trying to discredit her because of it.

Mod Annoucement:

 

Ironeyes is replacing Mynd.

 

Welcome!

Wait Razen so let me get this straight. Judging her claim, a mason claim, by the rock solid information provided by her partners flip and then questioning her claim of being EPs teammate when she had no pressure to do so is scummy? Really?

 

And when did someones coroner become trivial information? Last I checked a coroner is the information that we the town worked for and wanted to get after an entire days worth of discussion. I dont see that as trivial and you trying to downplay all of this just makes me suspicious of you.

Hello Ironeyes. :)

Welcome Marsh!

I'm a bit concerned that Wombat would come out so strongly against Arez and then vote someone else

 

Lily just did something similar and then voted her FoS which seems normal

 

Why didn't you vote Arez Wombat?

 

Because I after reading the pages after page 5 I changed my mind. You maf bro?

Shoulda said something then

It came off across really weird

Couldn't a player be both a mason and a power role?

 

But I do have a question for Lily, is EP even allowed to post on your "mason qt" after he died?

 

I would hazard the answer is a no, and the fact that you are saying you are posting EP's thoughts, when EP never talked about Nya or never outright told us he was suspicious of her, I think is just false. I really don't feel that dead players are allowed to continue posting game information, so I would feel that as a breach in my opinion.

 

So, vote LilyElizabeth.

 

Yes, he is, but not game related thoughts. He posted that WoT on the QT during the night. It is normal policy for dead players to be allowed to continue to post on QTs, and I don't know why there is a restriction on this game, but that's what I was told by BG.

FTR I usually don't allow dead players to communicate on QTs

Really, Nol? Nearly everyone else does, or used to, at least, back when I played more. I feel so old. There's a whole new group of mafia players now, most of which I don't even know well. But, in my experience, that's the way it is.

 

Incoming WoT....

Wait Razen so let me get this straight. Judging her claim, a mason claim, by the rock solid information provided by her partners flip and then questioning her claim of being EPs teammate when she had no pressure to do so is scummy? Really?

 

And when did someones coroner become trivial information? Last I checked a coroner is the information that we the town worked for and wanted to get after an entire days worth of discussion. I dont see that as trivial and you trying to downplay all of this just makes me suspicious of you.

 

Why are you assuming that BG provided all the information of EP's role in the flip when he was nightkilled? I think someone skimmed the rules...because there's a couple of rules there that would tell you exactly what you need to know.

 

I don't see it as scummy for her reveal at all. She didn't have to come forward and reveal that she was EP's teammate. She didn't have to post his thoughts from before. You see it - immediately everyone is hopping on her. Something that a scum player wouldn't want to happen. The fact that she's sharing his thoughts (and the fact that we know that he was town) leads me to believe that she is town as well. And the fact that you're making light of it is highly scummy.