Jump to content

Pokemon Mafia II: Return to Heart Island--GAME OVER--TEAM ROCKET WIN

Featured Replies

  • Replies 977
  • Views 26.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Now I know some of you are fine with lynching third party, but I can win with town and we are getting close to endgame, we can't afford to waste a lynch, this is why I was uneager to reveal.

I just realized that we don't have our doc, but I wasn't nightkilled so far. Why is that?

 

The only reason I can think of is that the GF is John Snow, Rand or Dap; people who I could have viewed last night, and the scum planned for him to get town credit by me viewing him. Or, possibly, the GF is the only scum left, and is one of the people I already viewed. Then they would have left me alive since I'm no longer a threat.

 

Actually you have me to thank for that.

Okay, do you guys buy Rand's claim?

To me, it sounds like desperate scum, but if you guys want to lynch dap instead on the chance that he's telling the truth, I'll hold of the hammer.

 

I think we should hammer him, personally.

Guys, I am the holder of Shuckle, I am a third party survivor, I understand that some of you don't like third party, but I win with town, and this late in the game, we can't afford a lynch on third party, we have to focus on mafia. I am almost sure that Dap is mafia, scummy reasoning to vote people, lazy scum hunting, and trying to seem like he was the hammer, I mean, I haven't even seen a case against me! Dap is just leading all of you guys to vote me, I think he is scum. the only other possibility I see is that there is only a GF left in the game and no mafia, but the way Dap has been acting, he really stands out to mafia for me.

Gotcha! Vote Rand

 

And Dap's next! :baalzamon:

Guess we might as well lynch the only person I haven't viewed town... Rand.

 

These are the two votes other than Dap's which I have already talked about, marsh we already know is the cop and he thought I was the only one left, then realized i wasn't. Matty just said to vote for me then Dap. There is no reasoning in this, don't know why. I think you just went with the first voter who was Dap in this one.

I am a survivor, I have no NA, I just have to either be alive at the end of the game or be one of the last 3 people alive.

Ok, assuming you are town, lynching me just gains mafia another day, and at day 7 with the rate of people randomly decreasing, we can't afford to just randomly lynch someone. Now I personally think that you are mafia, and i shall not that you have not replied to any of my arguments, but even if you aren't, we have to start looking for scum or they are going to ride to victory.

I told you why I voted myself. I was waiting for Iron

It was just something to do while I waited. It could of yielded some results, I would have been fine if there was a pile up and at least you would have known who to lynch tomorrow

I told you why I voted myself. I was waiting for Iron

It was just something to do while I waited. It could of yielded some results, I would have been fine if there was a pile up and at least you would have known who to lynch tomorrow

 

OK, I get the waiting for Iron thing, but why would you have been fine with a pile up? If you were town, then you wouldn't want to waste a day with a bad lynch, and we really wouldn't be able to get information because you were a legitimate vote and everyone who voted for you would not be mafia.

You were active enough to unvote if necessary and you would have been able to point at other people for doing something that was completely legitimate.

And I get that, that itself is not that suspicious, it's the fact that you tried to turn it around and said that you would have cased people based on that, which I do not agree with at all, and to me that seems like lazy scumhunting.

It was lazy but it still would have worked. Someone would have tried to hammer with little explanation thinking they would win and we could of seen who it was. (I thought self votes didnt get counted as well) so yea it would have been a fun little test

The rules don't say anything about self-votes, and yes someone would have hammered, but that person could have easily been town. I mean, let's look at someone we know is town (99.9% sure, if he is mafia, then the mafia have pulled out the most amazing play of all time), Marsh. He knew there were two of us, but he kept his vote on me, didn't really give reasoning, because you already voted for me, psychologically, if people can't decide who to vote for between two people, then they will vote for whoever has more votes.

Yes that's true. But at this point in the game we are nearing LYLO. Therefore the scum are looking for an easy kill. They would jump on a townie who they could kill and move on (they could claim I was trying WIFOM and i wasnt viewed)

Yes, I do agree that scum would jump on, but so would town, and being able to differentiate between the two might be difficult, especially trying to calculate different time zones and so on.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.