I think he is a scheming mafia plotter and that's why I voted him way, way, way back and that's why I'm voting him now.

 

If he turns out to be Town, I shall eat my hat!

Strange... Double post with two other posts in between ;D

Indeed womby. My role was no safer than a miller. Play on brothaman, I'm free to host now.

I think he is a scheming mafia plotter and that's why I voted him way, way, way back and that's why I'm voting him now.

 

If he turns out to be Town, I shall eat my hat!

Overdone.

I have my reasons

 

shush

Darthe, it's day one. Unless you're a daytime finder or a mafia, you don't KNOW anyone's alignment but your own (and there's probably a few other rare roles).

I suppose you would have made another roleclaim had you been a daytime finder 

 

 

I'll try summarizing why I think Tira and Des are connected over the weekend (and look up on Churchill, that keeps bugging me).

 

Well, Rand, that was the hammer.

 

Why do you insist on trying to discredit an uncountered cop?

Darthe, it's day one. Unless you're a daytime finder or a mafia, you don't KNOW anyone's alignment but your own (and there's probably a few other rare roles).

I suppose you would have made another roleclaim had you been a daytime finder 

 

 

I'll try summarizing why I think Tira and Des are connected over the weekend (and look up on Churchill, that keeps bugging me).

 

Well, Rand, that was the hammer.

 

Why do you insist on trying to discredit an uncountered cop?

I have my reasons

 

shush

Mafia.

Thank you Basel for allowing me into a wonderful game. I enjoyed playing to a great theme and would love to again next time.

Darthe's FoS list seems ok to me.  I am also wary of Thorum and Lenlo.  I have a town read on Ithi and a null read on Tina.

Wombat

Why do you insist on trying to discredit an uncountered cop?

 

It doesn't fit in with the other role reveals. I get the "both are important" thing, but there are roles that fit Churchill way easier.

 

I don't think he would be countered if false. "Churchill" would indeed be important, and become a mafia-target tonight. And declaring cop on the first day when not in danger of getting lynched yourself?

 

Again, I'm neither, but it doesn't feel right to me.

Their must be a Churchill. If you find another... Lynch all liars. Otherwise stick to it. Womby, read Ithi as an ISO.

Their must be a Churchill. If you find another... Lynch all liars. Otherwise stick to it. Womby, read Ithi as an ISO.

 

I'll do that during the night I guess.

Wombat

 

Why do you insist on trying to discredit an uncountered cop?

 

 

It doesn't fit in with the other role reveals. I get the "both are important" thing, but there are roles that fit Churchill way easier.

 

I don't think he would be countered if false. "Churchill" would indeed be important, and become a mafia-target tonight. And declaring cop on the first day when not in danger of getting lynched yourself?

 

Again, I'm neither, but it doesn't feel right to me.

 

We only have 2 other role reveals and assuming there's a cop, someone has to be cop.

Had I been the real cop, I would have waited till day 2 before revealing. That way, I would have had at least the one viewing without losing the doctor as well.

 

All of this hypothetically, of course.

I'm also assuming there's a Churchill.

 

If no one knows a connection between Churchill and doctors, ...    

 

Does someone else have a role that is not directly related to his character? No need to reveal either, just state they're not related. It seems like (almost?) everyone has a role, so that shouldn't be too much of a disclosure.

Now I think on it, that wouldn't work for the cop.

You would have gotten speed lynched and everyone would hate you. But you aren't cop and you're going through a backwards way to gain town cred if mafia and making yourself an easy target if town.

Do not do the dumbass reveal he just asked for doc! Jesus

Obvious docfishing is obvious.

Vocabulary never was my strongest point. You all know what I mean. 

Vocabulary Language never was my strongest point. You all know what I mean. 

Nope. Quiet thyself soon child, you punish mine ears and afflict my spirit with your words.

Ithiscum has gone quiet. Probably the best move until I am gone.

Wombat

 

Why do you insist on trying to discredit an uncountered cop?

 

 

It doesn't fit in with the other role reveals. I get the "both are important" thing, but there are roles that fit Churchill way easier.

 

I don't think he would be countered if false. "Churchill" would indeed be important, and become a mafia-target tonight. And declaring cop on the first day when not in danger of getting lynched yourself?

 

Again, I'm neither, but it doesn't feel right to me.

 

"there are roles that fit Churchill way easier"

 

Have you ever heard of the saying "Truth is too inconsistent to be a lie", or something alone these lines?

Had I been the real cop, I would have waited till day 2 before revealing. That way, I would have had at least the one viewing without losing the doctor as well.

 

All of this hypothetically, of course.

I'm also assuming there's a Churchill.

 

If no one knows a connection between Churchill and doctorscops, ...    

 

Does someone else have a role that is not directly related to his character? No need to reveal either, just state they're not related. It seems like (almost?) everyone has a role, so that shouldn't be too much of a disclosure.

The "losing the doctor" part doesn't work (as per the post after this one), since I didn't take into account the doctor would (in that hypothetical case) still be lost by protecting BB.