Gimili and Legolas were great pics though.

theoden is simply BA.

And Ian as Gandalf was preordained.

Blanchett wouldn't have been my pick for Galadriel either.

 

thing about tolkien is his women are untouchable goddesses and hence not available for movies... or... anything...

 

who would you have cast?

 

and hey hi howdy friend maw, stay with us this evening, please

Saruman. Well cast. Christopher Lee.

They need to make the Silmarillion.

they blended so seamlessly gandalf and saruman

Feanor, Fingolfin, etc.

you want the audibook i hook you up...

 

silmarillion be twenty movies

i hoep thy dont maek the silmariolion aftre the fiasco aht was the hobbit

Would love to see Morgoth on screen.

The fall of Gondolin.

besids dont thnk it wuold be posible, to much stuf in it evn if boook isnt so big

glorfindel but for the silly consonants...

Finwe, father of Feanor.

lol  i cuoldnt resist

Boo at Jackson for replacing Glorfindel with Liv.

lol  i cuoldnt resist

 

 

love this movie

Leaving out Tom Bombadil.

 

lol  i cuoldnt resist

 

 

love this movie

mos peple dont seme to - i thuoght it was...tolerble

Leaving out the barrow wights.