I just said that's how I read it Ithi.

 

I'm pushing Ed because right now he's the one I feel most surely about is mafia.

I have to disagree with you about how well they are playing, we don't know, they haven't got their night kills, so something isn't going right for them. And until the end we won't really be able to judge. I think it is very premature of you to think that. 

 

It would be more fun, if more people were around and participated as well...

Well obviously if we choose right today our lot will improve.

 

The thing is there are 9 people left. If there is a Lynch today there will be 8 people left. If their NK goes through there will be 7 people left.

 

That means only 4 to Lynch.

 

If there are 4 of them left then this is LYLO. And if there are 4 of them left - and we didn't manage to find any of them via a Lynch then I think that's quite good going actually.

 

And speaking for myself, I still honestly don't know who they are lol.

 

I'm kind of hoping for a Domino effect where we manage to find one today and that will bring the rest of them down.

 

Mish knows I've failed totally this Game. Because she knows I'm Town. I have to agree with her.

 

I know he's dead - but I Blame Turin

I have to agree about not knowing who they are, I have so many theories that keep going round in my head discounting someone as mafia then counting them as mafia. 

 

I need to go to bed soon as well...where is everyone, I think they have all run off on purpose.

I've been quiet? I've got 50+ posts and have only been in the game since about page 90. 

 

I think what we need right now is information because we need to be able to connect the dots this late in the game. I think Leyrann would give us the most info. Mainly about Rand and Mish. Ithi's been speaking more sense today and is being very cautious which gains her a little bit of trust as opposed to yesterday when she was all over the place, plus Ithi dying wouldn't tell me us much because she suspects everyone. Dap would also be a good info lynch, he's narrowly avoided it twice and two protective roles seems a bit much (not counting Rand + Nolder).

 

My money is on Leyrann, followed by Dap, then Rand for his iffy claims.

Antibiotics are wonderful things :)

I'm shooting Rand tonight.

 

That's what mish was taking about in regards to ed

 

How did ithi miss that and then mish miss it when she went back to look

BG I don't think info lynches are a good idea anymore, you had your chance for that

 

Also I'm gunna call BS on eds "viewing". I think he's just testing the waters there for a fake claim

 

I'm shooting Rand tonight.

 

That's what mish was taking about in regards to ed

 

How did ithi miss that and then mish miss it when she went back to look

Yah he said was gonna kill Rand, but she said he was a 1 x vig. That was quite a specific thing to say. The whole 1x thing?

 

Don't you think?

He said that on another night as well dap, so I don't think he was claiming a role, just causing a little havoc

sorry, no he said he was sending in a night action a couple of times. 

 

Getting late now, need my bed

Yes it's specific, but you both failed to mention that post and it annoyed me

 

There was a hint

I hardly ever quote and I knew what I meant.

I quote cos no one else seems to remember

 

I'm shooting Rand tonight.

That's what mish was taking about in regards to ed

How did ithi miss that and then mish miss it when she went back to look

I didn't read the whole thread; I looked on the pages where the claimings went on, and then searched the thread for the word "vig". That's why I missed it.

 

Good to know I didn't grab it from thin air though.

I have to try and remember. I can only quote one thing at a time and I can't very easily go back to find stuff.

 

I usually manage to hold the whole game in my head. It's like revision for exams way back when. You remember stuff for as long as you need to and when it's done you can forget it ever existed.

Is it bad that I remembered that it came about a page after the night started...

I just clicked in the link for night and we t forward too and there it was

I would probably had remembered better any other day <.<

 

 

:shudders:

I think is probably best to let Darthe know things like that - especially if you are dead and not allowed to post in the Game.

Ok - I would like some questions answered please.

Eddie ... Dap and Rand being Mafia. Can you tell us if this is just your opinion or if you have actually viewed them as such?

Cloud ... Have you been self protecting during the game?

Rand ... Why were you ONLY concerned about being shot at by Chuckles?

Do you mean during the night? I ended up thinking that ed was probably lying.

 

Also to talya, mirror can also often be given to town, and also cloud didnt protect me, and although you havent been lynched, people have generally been suspicious of you throughout the game, a thing mafia may take advantage of, and again cloud didnt protect me.

@ Rand. Why were you not concerned that the Mafia would try and kill you?

 

@ Rand. How do you know that Cloud did not attempt to protect you?

 

Because Cloud's kill was coming at me, and town PRs wouldn't try to stop it because thats what town agreed on, and there would be no reason for mafia to either

a) Stop it with one of their powers and then shoot me or

b) Have two shots on me and be redundant

 

 

 

Blatant OMGUS because I found out he was mafia.

No, you bandwagoned on what Ithi, Turin, and Dap were saying (which I don't think is an accurate case anyways) but even if it was a case, you didn't find anything out. Nice try to continue saying almost nothing though, maybe you're scared that you're finally being caught on hiding.

@ Rand. Why are you sure that Eddie didn't find anything out? A 1 x Mirror wouldn't have stopped an investigative role for more than 1 night - plus - he would have found something out even if you did Mirror. Please explain this.

 

@ Rand. In your list of who you think is Mafia and Town, you use the word Scum for the majority of those you claim to be suspicious of, but you use the word Mafia for Dap. Why did you use a different word for him?

 

a) If it was a cop view, then I expect him to say it was a cop view.  Plus, even if it was, it would have either reflected off, or would have said I was town.  The only option is a busdriver or something like that, but again, if he actually viewed me he would have said so, and he would also have been voting for me.  Therefore, the only option left is casing, and he didn't case me.

 

b) For the majority of people, I wouldn't know if they were either a third party (since we haven' seen any yet) or mafia.  However, for Dap, if he is scum, he is almost sure to be an RB, and I haven't seen a third party RB before (besides used in cult) because that wouldn't be too useful for a third party who has to survive/kill everyone.  Plus, most situations where he is mafia involve collaboration with others in plans, which means he would be mafia most likely.

 

 

Summary for each player that is in this game right now.

 

2. Ruairidh Misheru 2.0 - Town read because of visitor role, visitor

3. Ed2funy - Scum read, think he is mafia because of lurkiness and non-contributation, thinking possible strong PR, don't know role

4. Ithillian - Scum read because of play of switching between multiple suspects and going after PRs, vanilla

7. Talya - Stronger scum read if Dap is town due to jailkeeping action, weaker scum read if Dap is mafia because of previous reasons, vanilla?

12. Leyrann - Town read because of watcher claim and OPed mafia if I analyze the mafia as the rest of the people I have a mafia read on, watcher

13. Dicetosser Bgrishinko - Town read because of general play that has been straightforward, casing, and thought out votes, vanilla?

14. RandA lThor - Town, 1-shot mirror used up

17._Cloud - Town because unCCed doc, doc

18. dapianoplayer - Mafia read because of play going against masons and role being a perfect fit for a mafia roleblocker, however also an opposite town read because jailkeeper action could have very likely been the reason for the lack of a mafia kill.

 

People I think who are town in order, strongest on top(excluding myself)

Cloud

Ley

BG

Mish

 

People I think who are mafia in order

If Cloud says he self protected, Talya

Otherwise, Ed

Ithi

Dap

 

With 18 people in the game, I suspect either 4 or 5 antitown. Maw's dead, so thats 3 or 4 antitown. So basically right now, I am going to move Dap into a null spot

 

People I am confused about

Dap

 

because I don't know if there are 3 or 4 scum left, and Dap's combination of scummy play yet a role that seemed like it blocked a mafia kill are really confusing me. Unless if Cloud comes back and says he protected someone who was a likely target, I'm going to stay off of Dap today.

 

Waiting on Cloud's answer, but for right now, I'll put my vote Ed on the VC because right now him and Talya are about died, and he is more likely to have a good PR

Here is the post btw.

 

Also I just noticed that you said that Talya about died?

 

And you are voting Eddie because he is more likely to have a good Power Role

 

Lol, that should have been tied.  If I had meant died, that would have been horrible English, even for someone who doesn't have correct grammar all the time.  Plus sometimes I type up to 125 wpm, so I am easily able to make mistakes that are far more apart than that.  :P   You may remember my post in the Indy game near night.

I think you mean all situations when I'm mafia Rand, since I'm sure I've only been mafia once when you've been playing to my knowledge

I think you mean all situations when I'm mafia Rand, since I'm sure I've only been mafia once when you've been playing to my knowledge

 

What do you mean?

Lol you said in most situations I do plans and stuff

I'm pretty sure I've on,y even mafia once with you around, so you Mean all

Lol you said in most situations I do plans and stuff

I'm pretty sure I've on,y even mafia once with you around, so you Mean all

 

This sounds familiar, but I can't find it.  Out of curiousity, where is it?

However, for Dap, if he is scum, he is almost sure to be an RB, and I haven't seen a third party RB before (besides used in cult) because that wouldn't be too useful for a third party who has to survive/kill everyone. Plus, most situations where he is mafia involve collaboration with others in plans, which means he would be mafia most likely.

Dap, Mish, and maybe Rand.

 

Notice how Dap sat back and let others get muddled in all this to keep his hands clean? And how all of a sudden, I am on Mish's scum list? How she is so sure I am scum. And Rand went all cray.