Still betting on darthe. Odds of mafia, janitor and him all doing the same person, hmmmm

Talk about scummy misrep. Janitor is a mafia role. Youre acting like three separate people targeted one person and you're using that bias to attempt and make me look as bad as you possibly can. The odds of two people targeting the same individual are not that high but its also not impossible and in this case its what happened.

well it would have been cop, gunsmith, and mafia targeting wombat, and that does seem like a stretch, doesn't it, darthe?

 

ok, question for lenlo --

 

pray says his results said no symbiote.

 

what did your results say?

(but yes, not impossible. just not highly probable.)

 

Hah great play! Waiting a day to CC is way past expectations mate. unvote vote Len

you wanted ppl to think before jumping on your train, right? just cause Hally said so?

 

but you jump on this one without hesitation?

 

I must be missing something basic again.

 

it's ok, I do that....

Different scenario. My situation is suggestive buy not decisive. I could have done anything, all that the tracker knew was that I visited Womby. Here we have two people claiming a role that almost never shows up twice in a game. The pieces don't fit and thus we lynch one then the other and we are practically guaranteed to get scum.

well it would have been cop, gunsmith, and mafia targeting wombat, and that does seem like a stretch, doesn't it, darthe?

 

ok, question for lenlo --

 

pray says his results said no symbiote.

 

what did your results say?

For the point of this, if Hally followed rory last night and he revealed as cop today what do you think would have happened? We would have speed lynched him because we already had a cop claimed. Unless you're suggesting that we are both mafia then this argument, improbable as it seems, shouldn't hold up.

 

 

Hah great play! Waiting a day to CC is way past expectations mate. unvote vote Len

you wanted ppl to think before jumping on your train, right? just cause Hally said so?

but you jump on this one without hesitation?

I must be missing something basic again.

it's ok, I do that....

Different scenario. My situation is suggestive buy not decisive. I could have done anything, all that the tracker knew was that I visited Womby. Here we have two people claiming a role that almost never shows up twice in a game. The pieces don't fit and thus we lynch one then the other and we are practically guaranteed to get scum.

why so quick to jump Len and not pray tho?

 

that's the part I'm missing, you seemed to be completely buying his claim.

 

is there a solid reason to believe him over Len?

 

I just thought of a possible one but it's psych and that's a soft science and it'd wifom me in circles worse than this is doing.

well it would have been cop, gunsmith, and mafia targeting wombat, and that does seem like a stretch, doesn't it, darthe?

 

 

Well, Berf targetted Wombat N1. Not the same night he was targetted by Darthe.

 

well it would have been cop, gunsmith, and mafia targeting wombat, and that does seem like a stretch, doesn't it, darthe?

ok, question for lenlo --

pray says his results said no symbiote.

what did your results say?

For the point of this, if Hally followed rory last night and he revealed as cop today what do you think would have happened? We would have speed lynched him because we already had a cop claimed. Unless you're suggesting that we are both mafia then this argument, improbable as it seems, shouldn't hold up.

I was saying it was three visits, not two, and that's less probable. so ... that's all.

 

I'm not suggesting anything except... that's a lot of coincidence, I'm having trouble with it myself.

Anyway, going to sleep now. Will be back tomorrow morning.

I'd suggest taking dap up on his speed lynch offer and asking him to hammer and doing it fast in case the lynch does fail.

 

It will end the day so you don't need to worry about having to quickly lynch elsewhere

 

 

I don't buy the vig claim.

between he and Hally I find her the more believable, I don't see one vig in the same game being that much stronger than another, it's not balanced. the no coronorer report sounds very off, the immune to nks and lynches sounds very off, I think that's a third party and I think it's an sk.

 

It's not only the SK, I need to be lynched to have a 50% chance of death, or be targeted by two kills in a night

As I am the town Vig I assume SK must be the other (not to sold on hally being town)

But if hally is town, her and the mafia targetting me would also do it

 

 

Add to that the fact that he claims only an SK can kill him. Which he might just be. I agree that it doesn't look good, Cindy.

 

It's just two kills at the same time

 

Berf had viewed Wombat and I had viewed you. No symbiotes.

Please explain the bold

Cos in the show the symbiotes are good and bad (I think they had different names for them)

So do you see if someone has one or not?

If so does that mean everyone with one is mafia this game?

wish you'd let Len answer my question before you said that dap

Talya, are you sure that VC is right? I think I unvoted Dap. Instead, you have me voting him 2x :D

 

What happened to my votes?

 

sorry, I counted it as a vote not an unvote. 

 

VOTE COUNT:

 

Darthe (1): Hally

Hally (1): Des

Dap (2): Turin, cindy

Lenlo (3): Pray, Darthe, Notbob

Pral (1): Lenlo

 

With 13 it takes 7 to lynch

 

End of Day 3 in just under 24 hours...

 

COUNT DOWN TO DAY 3

wish you'd let Len answer my question before you said that dap

I don't think. That gave Len any info if he's mafia

But sorry

 

Berf had viewed Wombat and I had viewed you. No symbiotes.

Please explain the bold

Cos in the show the symbiotes are good and bad (I think they had different names for them)

So do you see if someone has one or not?

If so does that mean everyone with one is mafia this game?

 

 

I can detect symbiote in a person. From the wiki I could gather that symbiotes are Gou'ald parasites and are the villains of Stargate.Right?

My results just come up Clean and Not Clean. Clean meaning town and Not Clean meaning scum. 

 

Basic true false, yes no kinda thing.

 

 

 

Hah great play! Waiting a day to CC is way past expectations mate. unvote vote Len

you wanted ppl to think before jumping on your train, right? just cause Hally said so?

but you jump on this one without hesitation?

I must be missing something basic again.

it's ok, I do that....

Different scenario. My situation is suggestive buy not decisive. I could have done anything, all that the tracker knew was that I visited Womby. Here we have two people claiming a role that almost never shows up twice in a game. The pieces don't fit and thus we lynch one then the other and we are practically guaranteed to get scum.

why so quick to jump Len and not pray tho?

 

that's the part I'm missing, you seemed to be completely buying his claim.

 

is there a solid reason to believe him over Len?

 

I just thought of a possible one but it's psych and that's a soft science and it'd wifom me in circles worse than this is doing.

I didn't use any psych for this, just logic. Mafia can't be at endgame yet based on the 25% rule or even if its one degree higher. Thus CCing a cop is a death sentence. They shouldn't need to do that. They can NK. It really has no advantages that pay off for them so in this situation its been well established that yo u should believe the CC over the original claimant unless in a Lylo situation.

as dap said some who carry symbiotes such as tealc and the tokra are in general good guys.

 

sounds like the kind of response you'd figure might be the thing to say from a quick wikiing.

 

or maybe a limited cop role.

 

or maybe the games set up without tealc of tokra or rebel jaffah but...

 

clean and not lean make even less sense to me tho.

 

 

 

Berf had viewed Wombat and I had viewed you. No symbiotes.

Please explain the bold

Cos in the show the symbiotes are good and bad (I think they had different names for them)

So do you see if someone has one or not?

If so does that mean everyone with one is mafia this game?

I can detect symbiote in a person. From the wiki I could gather that symbiotes are Gou'ald parasites and are the villains of Stargate.Right?

The only part of this bugging me is.. why did you reveal? Your head was on no chopping b lock. You could have waited a day and brought two to the table if you aimed right.

 

 

Berf had viewed Wombat and I had viewed you. No symbiotes.

 

Please explain the bold

Cos in the show the symbiotes are good and bad (I think they had different names for them)

So do you see if someone has one or not?

If so does that mean everyone with one is mafia this game?

 

I can detect symbiote in a person. From the wiki I could gather that symbiotes are Gou'ald parasites and are the villains of Stargate.Right?

Check the wiki, cos I remember there were two types of symbiotes (might be from a different stargaze so I apologise)

One was bad and controlled a person, the other worked in harmony with people

The blonde girls dad gets one of the good ones in an episode and it saved him from dying

 

 

 

 

Hah great play! Waiting a day to CC is way past expectations mate. unvote vote Len

you wanted ppl to think before jumping on your train, right? just cause Hally said so?

but you jump on this one without hesitation?

I must be missing something basic again.

it's ok, I do that....

Different scenario. My situation is suggestive buy not decisive. I could have done anything, all that the tracker knew was that I visited Womby. Here we have two people claiming a role that almost never shows up twice in a game. The pieces don't fit and thus we lynch one then the other and we are practically guaranteed to get scum.

why so quick to jump Len and not pray tho?

that's the part I'm missing, you seemed to be completely buying his claim.

is there a solid reason to believe him over Len?

I just thought of a possible one but it's psych and that's a soft science and it'd wifom me in circles worse than this is doing.

I didn't use any psych for this, just logic. Mafia can't be at endgame yet based on the 25% rule or even if its one degree higher. Thus CCing a cop is a death sentence. They shouldn't need to do that. They can NK. It really has no advantages that pay off for them so in this situation its been well established that yo u should believe the CC over the original claimant unless in a Lylo situation.

worst case scenario, how close might lylo be?

 

 

 

 

Berf had viewed Wombat and I had viewed you. No symbiotes.

Please explain the bold

Cos in the show the symbiotes are good and bad (I think they had different names for them)

So do you see if someone has one or not?

If so does that mean everyone with one is mafia this game?

I can detect symbiote in a person. From the wiki I could gather that symbiotes are Gou'ald parasites and are the villains of Stargate.Right?

The only part of this bugging me is.. why did you reveal? Your head was on no chopping b lock. You could have waited a day and brought two to the table if you aimed right.

Well, thought about it yesterday. We have zero mafia and looking at the numbers, could not afford a mislynch. Not LyLo maybe but still bad.

 

Saw for a day and we were nowhere close to be sure of a scum. So, I thought it better to claim after probing Len.

http://www.stargate-sg1-solutions.com/wiki/Symbiote

http://www.stargate-sg1-solutions.com/wiki/Symbiote

And this now the most I know about Stargate. Im actually getting tempted to watch this show now with all the stuff im learnin bout it.

18 people could go a few ways. It could be five mafia on a team, four and an SK, or two teams of three. More than that I don't see. Perhaps a symp as the fifth. I don't see more than that even if all of the investigative PRs are true. It would be more sensible to give the mafia powers rather than numbers at that point.

 

Five is even stretching it tbh.

That eould give us at least a couple days assuming that Dap held his shots.