Hrm, is there?

I was joking.

 

It was clear that Mynd wanted this. I have no idea why he's gone and vanished after doing it though.

It is odd, starting to wonder about him.

Even with the battle 1 vs 1 going on, i still want to post my overal reads, as i had finally had the time today.

 

Thrax - a lot of defense. I'll say that he's neutral for me, as he's defending people i have on my town read list, for things i can understand. Now, besides him defending others, i didn't really have scum read list from him.

Len - Scum lean. As I said, it took him time to get active and take stances. He made 1 case but not a full list of reads. Also, I think his post 67 had a lot in common with what Despo said on his post 64. Then the what? when BFG claimed, looks a bit overdone.

Mynd - Scum lean too. I think that his catch up post 172 looks also like the 64 and 67. Then there's that sentence : Dice! Stop reading my MYND and posting my thoughts before I get to!!!!!! about Thane's PM content. It makes me think about buddying. I agree with Ithi's opinion on his reasoning about Thane : first he says Ithi has a weak case then votes him then he votes Thane. Strangely i noticed that he came up with the idea that Thane could have a more valuable role than VT but no one said anything. Which is strange, because when i enquired about Thane's possible, some players reacted thinking i was trying to convince everybody he was an oracle  ...

I also noted him parrotting csarmi on 220, and being ok with the idea of lynching town on 229.

When Ithi is posting about his alignement, he counterattacks saying she must be scum. He has not given any full reads, same as Len. and he's very concentrated on some players only.

Tina - too early to tell.

Turin - neutral. Same as Ithi, he's quite active, building cases. I tend to agree with some of his reasonings. But i noted that he's clearing Ithi and defended her  tone on post 208. I find it astonishing that people note the fact that i believe Thane is town but that no one says anything about Turin clearing Ithi. He made some votes, unexplained, Ithi didn't really asked him about this but asked questions to the voteed.

Despo - neutral leaning scum.  Locks clear people for no explanations first csarmi and ithi, then ithi turin and tsuki. I didn't really see his reasoning. Very friendly with Mynd says he needs to catch up with his game blah blah. then gently chastise him.  No full reads either.

Hally - no stance at first, but it is usual for her playstyle. Gives town reads more than scum reads... i'd say neutral.

BFG - neutral? she claimed and people tend to believe her claim fastly. Says Ithi has a tunnel vision but i don't think she played differently than her town self.
 

?Dawn?/replacement - neutral even though her catch up post mentions csarmi early claim but nothing else of what was going on with Thane.

 

Thane, Ithi, Tsuki, Dice, Csarmi - town reads

 

[unvote] Len

 

[v] Mynd [/v]

 

Chael, did you miss my being able to prove I'm town ?

yeah ?

you claimed something ... but that doesn't prove anything, imo

It's a town role that's able to be proven?

Vote count:

 

Mynd (5): Ithi, Turin, Csarmi, Tsuki, Chae

Ithi (1): Mynd

 

 

Not Voting (10): everyone else

 

 

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch.A deadline is now in effect.

 

DL is set for Tues. June 17th at 9 PM EST.

It would be amusing to have a Gladiator and a Governor on the Mafia team.

 

So one of them could issue some challenge and even if they lose they could be saved.

 

It is traditionally a Town role - but could technically be any alignment.

 

Also playing scrabble with someone who giggles cos they played 'boobies'.

 

Which is obviously a type of gannet

well when it is proven it will be proven... lol

i don't have anything else than a neutral feeling about your gameplay

I see what you did there

O.o

 

I didn't have to google "gannet"... I need help.

playing scrabbles? sounds nicer than trying to pull the computer away from the wee hands my one year old lol

Governor is NOT exclusively town. 

 

but would be a hilarious thing to have in conjunction with a mafia gladiator. 

Interesting how you guys are trying to cast doubt on it.  

 

Mafia Governors are overpowered in normal circumstances for obvious reasons - they can delay the lynch of a scumpartner for a Day, getting the full benefits of having that partner alive for an extra Night. However, scum-side Governors only tend to appear in games where there are plenty of other ways to render someone dead aside from the lynch.

 

I haven't seen a lot of killing going on, so it's unlikely

 

Also - If I was a scum role, I most certainly  wouldn't have outed myself, as I could save a partner in that way without ever speaking up.

Well of course if you were Mafia you would say you were a Governer and then use it and 'prove' yourself Town.

 

It's only a once shot thing usually so when it's gone it's gone. You'd be daft to not try and swing it as Town.

 

But it is usually a Town role.

 

It would just have been very funny - like an elastic noose, boinging Mynd up and down.

• Sometimes the Gladiator can choose more than one person - Also, so there are variations where they pick other people.

Yes ... but he did say that we should find out who people think is most Town. And then this challenge went up.

Interesting how you guys are trying to cast doubt on it.  

 

Mafia Governors are overpowered in normal circumstances for obvious reasons - they can delay the lynch of a scumpartner for a Day, getting the full benefits of having that partner alive for an extra Night. However, scum-side Governors only tend to appear in games where there are plenty of other ways to render someone dead aside from the lynch.[/size]

 

I haven't seen a lot of killing going on, so it's unlikely[/size]

 

Also - If I was a scum role, I most certainly  wouldn't have outed myself, as I could save a partner in that way without ever speaking up.[/size]

It is only Day 1.

Role Madness games are NOT exactly normal circumstances. People that try to push themselves as vetted without being vetted ping me like crazy.

 

As far as killing roles. We really don't know yet now do we? It is still early. We know that there probably isn't a day vig tho since Despo is still alive.

 

 

"I would NEVER do that as mafia" is another ping. 

 

Carry on tho since you can't be lynched today.

You just totally stole my day-vigging-Despo joke!

 

Although no-one noticed when I made it.

 

or my Terry Goodkind one.

 

maybe Cindy noticed and I'll get a laugh when I read the Deadthread.

 

I like it.

We both loled at your terry goodkind joke

Yes!