Jump to content

Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

Featured Replies

  • Replies 2.9k
  • Views 72.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Okay caught up (finally- stoppid guests kept interrupting)

 

Gotta say my wim is pretty low with all the replacements. Not lurkers either, it's like key figures in the game. Just makes everything else harder to get a good grasp on. Anyhoo.

 

Chae'Krak's claim before replacing out looks completely fake to me. She cryptically hinted at an action failing or being blocked earlier, and kept hinting at replacing out, then when no one takes the bait she complements Tsuki on his case on her, then claims town JOAT but doesn't say what action failed... then replaces out. Imo, if she knew she was about to replace out, she wouldn't have claimed like that before doing so, she would've left that to whoever replaced her. I think she claimed BEFORE replacing out to make it look more believable. Plus, I wanna test something-

 

[unvote]

 

[v]Thane[/v]

 

Thinking moar about it, I think Thane is a Symp. Perfect role for Irene Adler imo, and would explain Chae's odd defense of him. I think Thane was trying to signal to his teammates by calling out their roles like that. I think Chae might be a JOAT, but def aint town. Hallia is likely GF, I'm even doubting she has a Governor shot at this point, scum keeps trying to scramble to get any lynch going besides hers. I bet Tsuki is right and that she's Moriarti.

 

Speaking of which, Tsuki's train is dirrrrrrrty. Blech. The whole twilight thing couldve been another role- I remember seeing some other scum roles out there that tinkered with a lynch before when doing research for one of my setups, one was called Journalist, another was ... gah can't remember. Twilight thing could've been from one of those roles. Sorry I don't have enough time atm, otherwise I'd look those roles up. Def think something could be afoot there however.

 

Regardless, Thane is the perfect lynch today. If he's VT, town loses nothing essentially, since he's barely playing anyways. If he's a Symp like I believe, then this game gets busted wide open.

 

Scum!Thane>Scum!Chae>Scum!Hallia>Scum!....Csarmi I guess. Gotta go, will try and offer more later.

Tina or Pray for last scum spot.

 

If I'm way off base with the Thane/Chae thing, I'd take another look at Lenlo (Chae's bizarro vote his only saving grace this game), Turin (good deep wolf candidate), and NotBob (hunch).

i have my doubts about Hallia being GF.... As for Tsuki, yeah, i think he slipped somewhere and he would be the lynch to have today. We could get some information out of that.

 

As for me being symp? I'm more sympathetic for scum than for townfor the moment, because town is playing badly.... we could have had the game solves sooner but everybody was bickering over roles, characters and what they might be.

 

And NotBob, not even an explanation for the vote? Just like that? c'mon, you should at least try harder to look like town.

i have my doubts about Hallia being GF.... As for Tsuki, yeah, i think he slipped somewhere and he would be the lynch to have today. We could get some information out of that.

 

As for me being symp? I'm more sympathetic for scum than for townfor the moment, because town is playing badly.... we could have had the game solves sooner but everybody was bickering over roles, characters and what they might be.

 

And NotBob, not even an explanation for the vote? Just like that? c'mon, you should at least try harder to look like town.

 

I don't need to look like town.  I am town.  

[v]Thane[/v]

 

I could do Thane to. Him, Chae/Krak and CS are all good choices imo.

 

Vote count:

Hally (2): Turin, Tsuki

Tina (1): pral

Thane (2): NotBob, Des

Tsuki (4): csarmi, Hally, thane, Thrice

Chrak (1): Tina

Not voting (4): Ithi, BFG, Chrak, Len

With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch. DL is Mon. June 22nd at 9 PM EST.http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20140623T21&p0=422

 

 

is the deadline today or tomorrow?

DL was moved to Monday to let Chrak catch up and cause the mods way busy today.

 

 

Vote count:

Hally (2): Turin, Tsuki

Tina (1): pral

Thane (2): NotBob, Des

Tsuki (4): csarmi, Hally, thane, Thrice

Chrak (1): Tina

Not voting (4): Ithi, BFG, Chrak, Len

With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch. DL is Mon. June 22nd at 9 PM EST.http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20140623T21&p0=422

 

is the deadline today or tomorrow?

DL was moved to Monday to let Chrak catch up and cause the mods way busy today.

 

 

June 23 then?

 

 

 

Vote count:

Hally (2): Turin, Tsuki

Tina (1): pral

Thane (2): NotBob, Des

Tsuki (4): csarmi, Hally, thane, Thrice

Chrak (1): Tina

Not voting (4): Ithi, BFG, Chrak, Len

With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch. DL is Mon. June 22nd at 9 PM EST.http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20140623T21&p0=422

 

 

is the deadline today or tomorrow?

DL was moved to Monday to let Chrak catch up and cause the mods way busy today.

 

June 23 then?

yes there was math sorry

 

 

 

 

Vote count:

Hally (2): Turin, Tsuki

Tina (1): pral

Thane (2): NotBob, Des

Tsuki (4): csarmi, Hally, thane, Thrice

Chrak (1): Tina

Not voting (4): Ithi, BFG, Chrak, Len

With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch. DL is Mon. June 22nd at 9 PM EST.http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20140623T21&p0=422

 

is the deadline today or tomorrow?

DL was moved to Monday to let Chrak catch up and cause the mods way busy today.

 

June 23 then?

yes there was math sorry

 

 

no worries...lol

 

i have my doubts about Hallia being GF.... As for Tsuki, yeah, i think he slipped somewhere and he would be the lynch to have today. We could get some information out of that.

 

As for me being symp? I'm more sympathetic for scum than for townfor the moment, because town is playing badly.... we could have had the game solves sooner but everybody was bickering over roles, characters and what they might be.

 

And NotBob, not even an explanation for the vote? Just like that? c'mon, you should at least try harder to look like town.

 

I don't need to look like town.  I am town.  

 

That's what i've been saying the entire game. Nobody believes me, why should they believe you?

i have my doubts about Hallia being GF.... As for Tsuki, yeah, i think he slipped somewhere and he would be the lynch to have today. We could get some information out of that.

 

As for me being symp? I'm more sympathetic for scum than for townfor the moment, because town is playing badly.... we could have had the game solves sooner but everybody was bickering over roles, characters and what they might be.

 

And NotBob, not even an explanation for the vote? Just like that? c'mon, you should at least try harder to look like town.

 

*spit coffee* LMAO

 

for the record..... i doubt there's a single mafia on Tsuki's train right now.

 

*spit MORE coffee* The only thing that MIGHT make Thane Town, is I can't see scum letting him post crap like this. Of course, when someone's hanging from a cliff, sometimes you just cut him free so others don't die.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.