Jump to content

Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

Featured Replies

 

Just distancing?  I think it goes a little further than that.

Please stop with the combination self meta and "mafia would never..." defenses. The best distancing is over the top. knock down drag out battling because it is supposed to look real. 

 

 

 

@hallia    ^^^^ so much this!

  • Replies 2.9k
  • Views 72.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

How is it not? It nullifies it.  But I'll not argue over something so silly.

 

 

And no, I've mentioned it several times since, so why would I deny it?

Sorry Rags. But you are solid town for me. 

 

 

Have you read Despo yet? He has actually been less verbose so you might not grow your headache.

Haha I've played with you before and if you have one constant, it's that you prolly post more words than anyone else.

 

I haven't.  I got Lenlo, Tsuki and you as town-to-likely town and Chae, Csarmi and Thane as likely scum.  I'll knock him out real quick then likely be done for the night.

 

 

Just distancing?  I think it goes a little further than that.

Please stop with the combination self meta and "mafia would never..." defenses. The best distancing is over the top. knock down drag out battling because it is supposed to look real. 

 

 

 

@hallia    ^^^^ so much this!

 

Then by all means join me on the lynch if you feel so strongly that we're both scum?

a train is going from point A to point B    to DERAIL it would be to do something to stop it GETTING to point B.

 

Resetting or nullifying its trip is different. This is what a Govenor does afaik   It sends the train BACK to point A or makes it as if the train never left the station.

 

 

You wanna give us the mechanics of your govenor action hally?

Vote count:

 

Hally (2): Turin, Tsuki

Tina (1): pral

Thane (3): NotBob, Des, Len

Tsuki (4): csarmi, Hally, thane, Thrice

Chrak (1): Tina

 

Not voting (3): Ithi, BFG, Chrak

 

With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch.

 

DL is Mon. June 23rd at 9 PM EST.

 

http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20140623T21&p0=422

 

Hally  pay attention if you are gonna try and call me out on something

Despo is on Thane and Chae real quick. 

 

All it does is pardon a lynch that I choose, it's nothing out of the ordinary

But only before the vote is hammered, right?

 

Whoops, forgot that my Despo notes were in that quick response.

Notes? we don't need no steeeenking notes. 

 

:myrddraal:  :laugh:

 

Lol.

 

I usually take notes on people when I solo them.  Sometimes I share them with the thread, sometimes I don't. 

 

Despo was all over Thane and Chae very early on, so assuming they are the scum I think they are, he goes in my townie lean pile.

@Rags the crucial information you're missing is that Chae is my bonded (and I have a good idea about how she's playing Mafia and all) and Tgane is Char's husband.

 

Also Thane has some history of playing as scummy as possible when town.

Sup Rags. Welcome to the game. So far your reads generally seem to coincide with mine, and I had a town read on your slot prior to your arrival, so so far you's in good shape.

 

Welcome to the game Rags!

 

I have waffled over your slot, help me figure it out one way or the other.

 

looks-fake-to-oxbrzw.jpg

 

@Rags

 

Csarmi claimed Miller right outta the gate

 

Thanes been run up twice but not lynched because Ithi suddenly picked a fight with Mynd and Mynd Gladiatored her. Mynd lost.

 

Lenofinger fence sat during all this pouting cause he didn't wanna vote eith ithi or mynd.

Hallia revealed saying she was a govenor, but did it like she was leaving it up to us to decide if she should save the loser Gladiator. Did a weird sudden shift from liking Ithi to voting Ithi. I dont believe her

 

I was killed. Was Oracle.

 

My scum list consists of Hallia NotBob Chae and Tsuki. Tsuki is recent and is really because of his tone lately.

 

hope that helps

 

Good summary, but I think you're offbase with Tsuki. His tone has been ~ the same all game, he was the countertrain to both Hallia and Thane (both of whom I think are scum), and his WIM has been off the charts. Remember him collating everyone's reads lists?

 

 

@Turin


Chae submitted a vig shot on you and it failed.

 

 

 

he_chose_poorly.gif

 

 

 

Seriously tho. That was a bad choice. What happened to her firm view that Lenlo was mafia?

 

She took a shot at me, but I'm still alive.  What are the odds of that?

 

Did the mod really tell you that the shot failed? that seems odd. Usually it is left to you to figure out what happened once your bullet left the gun. I find this a lot odd.

 

 

Since you have claimed JOAT already and were willing to give your used action and target, Can we get your name?

 

 

Excellent point Turin. Remember D1 when Chae said she had ONE scumread, Lenlo, and had no reasoning to actually justify that single scumread? She never changed on that at any point that I recall, yet when she gets a Vig shot she doesn't shoot the ONE scumread she had out of all other players?

 

Yeahhhhh....... not buying it 'tall (my bad british impersonation of 'em saying "at all")

 

I did what I think was best.  Sorry you disagree.

 

By DERAIL, that's what I could've done, no matter how you misconstrue it.

 

 

How is it not? It nullifies it.  But I'll not argue over something so silly.

 

 

And no, I've mentioned it several times since, so why would I deny it?

 

Oh look, moar evidence of Hallia's scumminess.

 

:rolleyes:

 

Hallia firsts accuses Turin of misconstruing her, so when he clarifies his position and what he was talking about, she basically goes "Semantics, can't be bothered".

 

:dry:

 

I really, really, really, really, REALLY hope someone gets a vig shot tonight and takes Hallia out. Really don't wanna have to waste two days lynching her if she has a Governor shot after all. She's pinging so hard it's crazy.

 

@Rags the crucial information you're missing is that Chae is my bonded (and I have a good idea about how she's playing Mafia and all) and Tgane is Char's husband.

Also Thane has some history of playing as scummy as possible when town.

 

Oh riiiiiight I forgot you were confirmed town Csarmi, so everyone can trust your read of Chae, and that you can read her rock solid 100%

 

:rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

 

Srs do, your now hardcore defense of Thane just reeks. Just saying that he looks scummy cause it's in his meta or something. I've seen Thane be a bit awkward before, but NEVER this scummy. Disappears when focus shifts off him, unnatural reactions to like everything, claims to be VT Irene Adler, a borderline scummy character, brings up setup talk in a role madness game even tho he's supposedly so new and don't know what he's doing, pulls names out of a hat instead of ACTUAL scumhunting, then pretty much just AtE's when peeps start pushing hard for his lynch.

 

If you think that looks townie Csarmi, well then you're prob just full of it and scum.

I'm not defending Thane. I think he's more likely to be Mafia than town.

 

I'm explaining stuff Rags don't know.

 

You can put your attitude where the sun don't shine.

Pretty easy to confirm that I mean what I say BTW.

 

Just lynch me. Vig me.

 

Also I called for a shot on Turin. Did you miss that?

Pretty easy to confirm that I mean what I say BTW.

 

Just lynch me. Vig me.

 

Also I called for a shot on Turin. Did you miss that?

So that's supposed to justify Chae shooting Turin even tho her ONLY scum read all of D1 was Lenlo?

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.