Jump to content

Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

Featured Replies

Thane then Chae then Csarmi then Hallia twice if no one's shot her by then.

 

If we haven't won by that point, then we can reassess. But those 4 have a mountain of evidence against them.

  • Replies 2.9k
  • Views 72.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

You sound like s broken record.

 

What about the rest?

 

Fixing your reads like that and not even following other scenarios pings especially as town and I think Chae is 95%+ to be one.

  • Author

Vote count:

 

Hally (1): Turin

Tina (1): pral

Thane (4): NotBob, Des, Len, Tina

Tsuki (4): csarmi, Hally, thane, Thrice

 

Not voting (4): Ithi, BFG, Chrak, Tsuki

 

With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch.

 

DL is Mon. June 23rd at 9 PM EST.

 

http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20140623T21&p0=422

 

Unchanged from the last VC, unless I missed one. A little more than 14 hours till DL.

You sound like s broken record.

 

What about the rest?

 

Fixing your reads like that and not even following other scenarios pings especially as town and I think Chae is 95%+ to be one.

 

I think I've made it abundantly clear throughout the game that I'm willing to adjust my reads accordingly. I started off believing your Miller claim, for instance. But your lack of effort, or explanation for really anything, in addition to your hardcore townread of Chae even tho she looks anything but town to me, has all led me to believe you're scum.

 

Claiming Miller out the gate is one thing. Claiming Miller but then never actually putting in an effort to try and prove your towniness to others is a completely different story. It seems you've been trying to skate by on the Miller claim as long as posssible. Reminds me of the last BT game I played where you tried skating by on the JK claim (when you were scum)

 

Why would anyone care if your action failed? You were Roleblocked. It happens.  By stating you are JOAT, you just ensured yoe ARE RBed for the rest of the game, assuming you survive the day... Put your money where your mouth is - what action did you try?? Nice way to make it seem I am casing YOU, instead of your whole team. In fact, during the case, I never mentioned your English mistake even once. I DARE YOU TO FIND IT.

 

Nice that my main 3 scum show up. Where's the HubbyScum?

 

Poor Hallia. GF to this group... at least CS has avoided blatant misrepping to OMGUS me. Again, Chae, go find anywhere in my WoT where I mentioned your grammar issue. I will wait.

 

This pinged to me hardcore. Town should care. She may actually be that role. but then he goes Action fishing..

 

Tsuki seems to be getting more and more aggresive and the tone of these posts is one i dont like. When asked a question he has a glib line rather then an answer.

 

unvote vote Tsuki

 

 

This vote stank.

 

Made to create the Tsuki train as the leading one and keep it maintained. Not a strong reason for the vote either. 

Looks more like Thrice was waiting for an opportunity to vote tsuki.

 

Tsuki is town, I don't see his reads as correct but I can sense the genuineness in giving out his reads. 

 

Tina or Thrice - that should be the lynch today. Tina is staying under the radar. Not talking about her being busy but more of her posts staying in the safe zone and not taking even slightly aggressive stance, 

I don't really feel like addressing this again so this is the last time I'll do.

 

I'm not putting in more effort cause I can't. This isn't likely to change during the game and it may get worse.

 

If you don't like it, I'm sorry but there is nothing I can do right now and actually I don't even care.

 

 

Vote count:

 

Hally (1): Turin

Tina (1): pral

Thane (7): NotBob, Des, Len, Tina, thrice, Csarmi, tsuki

Tsuki (2), Hally, thane

 

Not voting (3): Ithrahnarok, BFG, Chrak

 

With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch.

 

DL is Mon. June 23rd at 9 PM EST.

Vote count:

 

Hally (1): Turin

Tina (1): pral

Thane (8): NotBob, Des, Len, Tina, thrice, Csarmi, tsuki, thane

Tsuki (1): Hally

 

Not voting (3): Ithrahnarok, BFG, Chrak

 

With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch

 

That was the hammer

 

It is now TWILIGHT

Thane, a bit of advise if you decide to keep playing mafia. When you are town do not ever hammer yourself unless:

1.) deadline is approaching to avoid a random if you are VT.

2.) your lynch will immediately result in a mafia lynch the next day.As in a cc situation.

 

 

Then make sure that  you have your reads out in as logical a manner as you can. This way the rest of the town can try to glean information from what you are saying knowing that you had no nefarious agenda.

 

I am hoping that Thane is mafia, but I really don't think so. 

 

A bit disappointed with this lynch. Especially based on reading the last page. Csarmi needs to go. That thinking that Chae was justified in her shot choice because he said so reeks. 

 

Still think that most likely mafia are Csarmi, Chrak, Hallia. a few candidates for the remaining slot.

 

Len: especially if Chrak is mafia. The entire D1 thing without shooting him becomes a huge distancing event allowing her (and Csarmi) to keep their votes off anyone else. It was very unlikely that Len was gonna get lynched with the weak "case" used. 

 

NotBob: been slinking about most of the game content to snipe here or there. Nudging things along the way he wants without really taking the lead.

 

Tina: suspicious by absence but some of the posts when here have looked Townish.

 

BFG: (see Tina) in her defense she did replace earlier than expected and her  VT claim looks solid. 

 

Despo: (DEEP WOLF/"Thinking cap") Agreeing maybe a bit too much. Especially with Ithi early on. Has taken up the Adler as scum line dropped by Mynd. (last thing about this, I hope. In a game that has the flavour based upon the original books it makes more sense to me to use what is in those books and not what was added a century later to a film or TV adaptation of those books. So anyone that wants to paint that character in a negative light should cite evidence from the books themselves) 

 

Dice has looked better than X since replacing in. Tsuki looks like I expect him to, meaning a bit rough tongued but working to solve. Pral also seems like I expect him to be, following his own leads and not concerned when they don't match what is popular.

Turin - as devil's advocate, without non-canon, Moriarty is nothing but an old man mentioned in two stories, notable only for mild skills at fisticuffs, and his math skills.

 

other than that, Thane, LISTEN TO TURIN. Never go out without making sure everyone knows exactly where you stand. Giving up sucks.

I told you I'm not Mafia. Any further push without an actual vote will be treated as a scum claim.

 

You had the whole day to vote me.

 

Turin stinks.

@Thane - I agree with Turin. I'd add that you should not ever do that as Mafia either unless you got a very good reason to.

I told you I'm not Mafia. Any further push without an actual vote will be treated as a scum claim.

 

You had the whole day to vote me.

 

Turin stinks.

LOL

FTR:

 

A game this size with role madness is very likely to have a miller.

 

That has two trival consequences:

 

1) Mafia would be a fool to fake claim Miller unless in a desperation situation.

2) Makes a lot of sense to believe the Miller claim cause there is likely to be one.

 

So yea I'm as confirmed town as it is possible.

 

Kind of having enough of the snipes tho. Keep the wifom up eh?

 

So yea from a logical point of view it makes no sense to lynch me ever in this situation... But if y'all want to, be my guest. Make sure to pay attention to who pushed it, when and how.

I prefer my lynch over Chae BTW. That should tell you smth about how strong my read on her is.

 

Can I be wrong? Doubt it... But possible.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.