Jump to content

Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

Featured Replies

@BFG - I haven't changed my opinion on early hammers. Tina's vote was the hammer by my count. I added an extra vote so that it's clear even if there are some shenanigans or errors. Normally I wouldn't hammer there.

  • Replies 2.9k
  • Views 72.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

@Turin

 

Assuming me and Chrak are town. And for now let's accept that you read Ithi correctly.

 

Who should we be lynching?

@Dice - I used the words "all but confirmed". And yea, sux to lose the 2x Oracle there it'd have been very useful in this setup.

Despo doesn't seem to be happening (even though it should).

 

[unvote]

 

[v]Tina[/v]

 

I could move to Lenlo or IthRags.

I don´t really understand the votes on me. Is it because I´m not very active? As I have said before (maybe not in this game?), don´t let my activity level decide if I´m town or mafia. I don´t expect to get a free pass but my activity level is what it is right now. 

 

Someone thought it was strange that I changed to Thane yesterday. Note that I had been suspicious of him before my vote on Chae too. I could have voted any of them. With Thane gone I´m going with Krak today. His vote on Rag doesn´t make him look any better. 

 

I think Turin has a good case on Csarmi. 

Krak, voting my tip top town read is not making me think you are town.

 

At least you are admitting that your N1 action seems to be mishandled.

Unfortunately, so was your N2 action. I guess the good news is you are drawing the blocks and allowing others to perform their jobs. Hopefully it will bear fruit soon.

 

 

Lol I never defended Chae's action N1.  And I certainly didn't submit it.  So are you finally realizing that Chrak is town?  The way you've phrased this post seems to say you are.

 

 

And I'm not sure why us having different reads would make you think I'm scum unless it was end game and it was MYLO.  

Anyways, up waaay earlier than I have been in months (at least of my own free volition) and reading up.  Hopefully I'll get some concrete reads…although Wimbledon showing at my local coffee spot isn't going to help me move any quicker.

Seriously.

 

I have 260 posts, even though I haven't been even close to as active and hard-working as I tend to be. I'm happy to answer any questions or a detailed case (I think I've been very honest and transparent).

 

If you wanna lynch me - come at me.

 

But posts like "I think Turin has a good case on Csarmi" aren't going to cut it.

 

@Krak - I think Turin has more and he had been quite straightforward with his suspicion on me from the start (though I can hardly remember what his points are except whether I'm >rand to be miller or scum). My bad.

I don´t really understand the votes on me. Is it because I´m not very active? As I have said before (maybe not in this game?), don´t let my activity level decide if I´m town or mafia. I don´t expect to get a free pass but my activity level is what it is right now. 

 

Someone thought it was strange that I changed to Thane yesterday. Note that I had been suspicious of him before my vote on Chae too. I could have voted any of them. With Thane gone I´m going with Krak today. His vote on Rag doesn´t make him look any better. 

 

I think Turin has a good case on Csarmi. 

 

 

It's posts like this one that make you look bad, not your activity level.  

 

1) It's helpful if you provide evidence instead of saying "note"

2) Why doesn't my vote on Rags make me look better?  Does it make me look worse or were you just repeating what Turin already said because you feel that your reasons for voting me aren't good?

3) Saying you think Turin has a good case on CS isn't a good way to go about agreeing.  It looks like your just agreeing to be agreeable.  You don't give any particular parts you agree with, it's a nudge against CS without you outright saying you find him scummy.  It's a good way to play both sides and ride the wave with whomever wins.

 

 

I don't like this post.  It's a bad attempt at justifying a vote and waffles on the topic of CS which seems to be quite divisive.

@mods

 

 

Could we get the post with EoD and final vote counts updated pretty please?

Sorry, Basel won't be able to edit till were home tonite and that could be later than usual.

 

If you tell me which vcs and ends of day you're looking for I'll try to put it in my reserved post on page 1, but I'm on mobile blech and at work so it'll take some doing.

unvote

 

 

 

@Hallia - What do you think about Dice 2.0?

 

@Len - Same question

 

 

@Des - How do you feel about a Hallia lynch? 

 

 

 

 

 

Town reads on Pral, BFG, Tsuki

 

Leaning town: CS, Des, Turin

 

Leaning scum: Rags, Hallia, Len

 

Null: Dice 2.0

 

 

 

Still reading but trying something newish as far as rereading goes.

Hi Dice!

 

 

I hope this version of you is town too.  If not I'll figure it out eventually (if I can convince my haters of the obvious).

 

 

But to the question at hand, why are you voting Tina?

@krak, I think there is a possibility that you are town. That is why it troubles me that you are using your action on, not to.mention, voting someone I have as solid town. My basic case on csarmi is that he has attempted to pass himself off as confirmed town from the moment he claimed even tho he isn't. His unreasonable sheep vote onto Len. His change on ability tovread Chaelca which did not result in him being willing to accept my solid town Ithi read. His use of the argument that there is "no way" mods gave out fake role claims to mafia for this game. That hallia has made the same arguments in defending role claim. The way they followed in lockstep together early.

 

If I can't vote csarmi or chrak today.my vote is going on hallia. Her overall play has pinged the most.

 

Others to consider are:

Len. He worked along with hallia during the d1 Thunderdome. Something else bothered me

 

Dice. More from X on d1. But he just nudged a bit at me. If just paranoid then understandable.

 

Despo. Has followed a bit more than normal. The calling Thane as symp for the reason he gave pinged. That looked a lot like Despo in full on bus mode.

 

I don't have many solid or even likely villagers atm. And off to drive again soon. I will be able to give short thoughts and adjust vote as needed. But not much more.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.