Jump to content

Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

Featured Replies

  • Replies 2.9k
  • Views 72.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

I'm Thaddeus Sholto, Town Miller.

 

 

You're missing the point I think. Miller is a negative utility role. Usually better off dead.

 

So you for anything for now Thane?

 

 

 

This is like "How to out yourself completely within the game's first few pages 101". Thane wants to keep wifom alive on the Miller... which is yeah incredibly scummy. He's also overstating how willing he is to find scum this game, just needs more people checking in and talking, that's all! Gee willickers!

 

 

 

You yourself said the role is better off dead, and Despo comes in and says WHAT? Can't hear you... Oh, right, cause Hallia just used a PR to KEEP THE WIFOM ON THE MILLER.

Makes her look HORRIBLE.

Yea that was on day one, before I realized how strong a miller claim is in such a setup. I was wrong.

 

And Hally used her PR to prevent a mislynch. Couldn't be used better for town.

And Hally used her PR to prevent a mislynch. Couldn't be used better for town.

 

Except that several people have pointed out how it would also have been used to great effect (especially in this instance) if she were scum...

1343414304078.gif

Yea that was on day one, before I realized how strong a miller claim is in such a setup. I was wrong.

 

And Hally used her PR to prevent a mislynch. Couldn't be used better for town.

It could be used to prevent a mislynch on someone thats actually town.

Yea please let me know how you think her role could be used better. Genuinely interested.

Or, say you are town which I dont think you are, it could be used to pardon someone who doesnt have a warehouse full of wifom to their name.

Yea please let me know how you think her role could be used better. Genuinely interested.

 

 

By not saving someone with so much bloody WINE on them. Really, dude, really? You say you were wrong about the Miller role?? I put a bullet in your head, just to end this crap.

Also you need to decide whether you think I'm scum...

 

Maybe not. But you need to be DEAD. It is the only way people were going to pay any attention to your reads. You yourself said you played like crap this game, can't put in the effort, etc etc.

You have yet to CASE anyone, active scumhunt, or anything but sow wine. All you do is "My bondee is town, I is perfect read and haz never been wrong."

Cause I got mislynched. She read it properly and saved me. Which is the optimum of the role's usage.

Except because of the amount of wifom surrounding you and the fact that your scum, we are going to lynch you AGAIN which basically wasted her role. Its so much better to use it one someone who isnt surrounded by enough wifom to sink a ship.

 

You know what screw it, im going to go cry in a corner until the world makes sense again and people stop talking nonsense.

 

 

Yea please let me know how you think her role could be used better. Genuinely interested.

 

By not saving someone with so much bloody WINE on them. Really, dude, really? You say you were wrong about the Miller role?? I put a bullet in your head, just to end this crap.

Again, how on earth got someone mislynched who was surely town and worth saving then? Without wine.

What about Chak? Willing to vote for them?? Oh, wait, anothe common-denominator scum read you think is town...

 

 

Yea please let me know how you think her role could be used better. Genuinely interested.

 

By not saving someone with so much bloody WINE on them. Really, dude, really? You say you were wrong about the Miller role?? I put a bullet in your head, just to end this crap.

Again, how on earth got someone mislynched who was surely town and worth saving then? Without wine.

 

 

How about someone who's role actually would have HELPED town. What if someone CC's a Doc claim, but the Wine makes it so that the person most likely to be town is lynched?? Oh, wait, can't save THEM now because the bloody miller is alive...

 

 

Also you need to decide whether you think I'm scum...

Maybe not. But you need to be DEAD. It is the only way people were going to pay any attention to your reads. You yourself said you played like crap this game, can't put in the effort, etc etc.

You have yet to CASE anyone, active scumhunt, or anything but sow wine. All you do is "My bondee is town, I is perfect read and haz never been wrong."

That's blatantly false.

 

So false it just passes my suspension of disbelief on you...

 

I need to be dead cause you're scum and tgad help you right? That it?

What about Chak? Willing to vote for them?? Oh, wait, anothe common-denominator scum read you think is town...

I'm not voting someone I'm 99% sure to be town. You mad bro?

 

 

Also you need to decide whether you think I'm scum...

Maybe not. But you need to be DEAD. It is the only way people were going to pay any attention to your reads. You yourself said you played like crap this game, can't put in the effort, etc etc.

You have yet to CASE anyone, active scumhunt, or anything but sow wine. All you do is "My bondee is town, I is perfect read and haz never been wrong."

That's blatantly false.

 

Prove it.

 

What about Chak? Willing to vote for them?? Oh, wait, anothe common-denominator scum read you think is town...

I'm not voting someone I'm 99% sure to be town. You mad bro?

 

Cause you've never been wrong, correct? Never ever said that before, then been wrong?

Seriously when do we lynch Lenlo?

 

I find it hard to believe that I'm the one noticing he does NOT play at all just keeps commenting on how I'm surely scum. Oh and wine.

 

 

 

 

Also you need to decide whether you think I'm scum...

Maybe not. But you need to be DEAD. It is the only way people were going to pay any attention to your reads. You yourself said you played like crap this game, can't put in the effort, etc etc.

You have yet to CASE anyone, active scumhunt, or anything but sow wine. All you do is "My bondee is town, I is perfect read and haz never been wrong."

That's blatantly false.

 

Prove it.

Read the thread maybe? You are ridiculous.

Seriously when do we lynch Lenlo?

 

I find it hard to believe that I'm the one noticing he does NOT play at all just keeps commenting on how I'm surely scum. Oh and wine.

Case him. Scum hunt.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.