With everything that has happened I am still 100% alright with a Lenlo lynch.

 

 

I highly suggest that's what happens today.

:(

Look mate, either way town benefits.  

 

If you flip survivor we get a realistic and more accurate look at numbers.

 

If you flip mafia well, you know.

That said, what are the chances there's a survivor and a miller?

And if both are in the game, I would expect scum to have 3 players not 4.

Look mate, either way town benefits.  

 

If you flip survivor we get a realistic and more accurate look at numbers.

 

If you flip mafia well, you know.

But I wanna wiiiiin

 

That said, what are the chances there's a survivor and a miller?

Pretty actually looking at all the positive utility roles town has. Seriously, the only negative utility town role weve seen so far is Miller and im not even sure hes telling the truth.

 

Look mate, either way town benefits.  

 

If you flip survivor we get a realistic and more accurate look at numbers.

 

If you flip mafia well, you know.

But I wanna wiiiiin

 

That said, what are the chances there's a survivor and a miller?

Pretty actually looking at all the positive utility roles town has. Seriously, the only negative utility town role weve seen so far is Miller and im not even sure hes telling the truth.

 

 

 

You're not even sure he's telling the truth?

 

 

Look mate, either way town benefits.

 

If you flip survivor we get a realistic and more accurate look at numbers.

 

If you flip mafia well, you know.

But I wanna wiiiiin

That said, what are the chances there's a survivor and a miller?

Pretty actually looking at all the positive utility roles town has. Seriously, the only negative utility town role weve seen so far is Miller and im not even sure hes telling the truth.

You "aren't sure I'm telling the truth"?

 

You been doing nothing but voting me and sniping me and calling me scum for three days.

I havnt liked CS's emo play and then complete switch in how he was acting the moment he wasnt under threat of being lynched. I dont like it. Ive been pushing him for acouple of days now actually.

Which is exactly why I think you slipped when you said "I'm not even sure he's telling the truth."

 

 

 

 

Im sorry phrasing for that was off, but I recognize the fact that im not infallible. 

You've done nothing except push him.  You practically took over the case on him allowing Despo to look elsewhere.

I havnt liked CS's emo play and then complete switch in how he was acting the moment he wasnt under threat of being lynched. I dont like it. Ive been pushing him for acouple of days now actually.

You done nothing else whatsoever actually. Since page 55 or do. Can't iso.

If you're survivor you deserve to lose. Don't think you are tho.

If you're survivor you deserve to lose. Don't think you are tho.

Well arnt you being harsh. Im sorry your scum CS, no need to get pissy about it.

So why do you think CS is scum when you think it's perfectly likely that there is a miller and a survivor in the game?

 

no im not claiming VT. my thinking has been that yes there is always one non powered role in a madness game. i thought that role was innocent child.

Cool. Hard claim VT Sir Henry Baskerville.

BFG

So why do you think CS is scum when you think it's perfectly likely that there is a miller and a survivor in the game?

I think its possible. Sorry wrong word there. Possible. Town has next to no negative utility roles that weve seen so that means 1 of 2 things

Either A) Scum have some very powerful roles 

or B) There is more than just town and scum in this game.

 

Its also possible there are negative utility roles that havnt revealed or dont know that they are negative utility roles, but I dunno about this. 

 

So short Possible, dont believe it.

 

 

See how we were all having a nice debate ... and then the challenge goes up.

 

And then up pops Len and Hallia, out of nowhere, to cheerlead the lynch on me.

 

Remember that people.

 

 

 

Goodbye Mynd.

Yay for blatant misrep! I was composing a post before that thunderdome went down, so I just included it in it. Youll also notice I corrected my statement about who started the thunderdome and that it wasnt you who I was going after. It was Turin. I thought you and Mynd were both being stupid for distracting us from Thane/Chae.

Hah.

 

 

Len, how sure are you that they're both town? Because I can derail the thunder dome.

Im pretty sure. I dont think Ithi or Mynd are scum, I still think those spots belong to Chae, Thane and X.

QFT

 

Read the whole exchange tho.

 

BTW Len's play until then is to safe-snipe people with talks like "whoa stop there y u say stuff like if Thane flips vanilla BFG can't be".

 

 

 

 

Len, how sure are you that they're both town? Because I can derail the thunder dome.

Im pretty sure. I dont think Ithi or Mynd are scum, I still think those spots belong to Chae, Thane and X.

I'm pretty confident my Chae is town.

And im pretty confident shes not, so were at an impasse.

 

Anyways im leaving I have a fathers day lunch to get to with family.

Poor Len.

I know right? Everyone here has some bonded to love them and all that jazz, while im here all alone in the corner drinking my juice box.

 

Gotta go!

CS iz still town.

Well, I am not usually active on weekends. Today is no exception either

 

However, have caught up so far.

 

I believer the miller claim. This is a role madness game and a scum taking a risk like that would be stupid. Cop, role cop, LD - anyone can easily vet it. Nope, unlikely.

 

Turin and Ithi are so clearly town here. Their questions are pointed and a genuine intention of catching scum. There are numerous posts against Thane, mynd which demonstrates this.

 

X vs Tsuki seemed forced. It was a very minor point that they were arguing and yet not voting each other. It tool Ithi's persistence to get Tsuki to vote. I smell a classic distancing here. The posts did not feel natural at all.

 

Len is looking townish. So, is Chae. It is more of a meta in their reads.

 

Mynd tries to make sense but gets stuck in the rut of reading a player based on his role. I think he is town though, at leats by the tone of posts.

 

Thane stutters at places and some of the posts seems blatantly scummy. However, I have obseved that he does it even when he is town. His push against me, despite knowing that I am not active on weekends, looks desperate. However, as I said, I have seen him doing this and gut feel says he is town.

Also, both Thane and BFG have claimed VT. Strange in a role madness game but I wouldn't use that for scum reads. POst-wise BFG seems town.

 

 

Hally is still null for me. Not a lot of posts but tough to read her so soon.

Dawn/NotBob is also null.

Tina has said that she has been a bit busy and so far she looks townish. Though I am suspicious of her as she tends to be very careful when she is scum. Null for now.

 

I don't like this post by Des. Seems to be going against easy players - Thane and Chae and trying to link Csarmi along with them. Slightly subtle but he is giving his reads before his WoTs. Leaning scum for me.

 

Dice's post has been pointed out by others, Len and Tina, as to how it is scummy. I had the same impression when I read it first. Looks like Dice is trying to set up lynches here. Scummy.

Pray consistency. Look at his reads.

 

 

 

2. Len is Mafia - Trying way to hard to put off making that list, trying to get down EXACTLY what can't be confirmed.

 

 

What? Im not putting off anything I said id make it later tonight because I had some plans with friends. Guess what time it is Tsuki? Later tonight. And also it was a legitimate question. Can an LD get a null read if someone is town and you say someone else is town with a post? Cause logically that player would have no way of knowing 100% the other player is scum. If the LD didnt get a null, they got a real true/false answer then it can virtually be used as a cop role.

 

 

1. Thrax(getting replaced) is Mafia - I cant remember the exact reason and need to do a reread for that but I have him down in notes as scum.

2. Len is Town, cause im me.

4. Dawn/NotBob is Town - Null.

5. Tina is Town - Town

6. Turin is Town - Begrudgingly town, though I really do detest the way hes been playing this game. Its so annoying to have what looks like almost unconditional def of someone and its really annoying to play against cause you cant talk someone out of something like this.

7. Despo is Town. - Scum hunting well, putting in work. Like it.

8. Hallia is Town - Actually null, but for the purposes of this list ill put her town.

9. Chae is Mafia - Def of Thane, subsequent posts and horrible cases all lead me to her being scum

10. Ithi is town - Again, begrudgingly town. I just dont like how Turin and Ithi play together, its almost always 2v1 against them regardless of alignment in the game.

11. Thane is Mafia - Dudes all over the place, that self vote was horrendous and imo he pretty much disappeared once Ithi and Mynd got into it, saving his bum

12. Tsukibana is Town - Town

14. Charis/BFG is Town - I liked the VT claim and the way shes been playing.

15. Pral is Town - Sadly, though I wish he was mafia. He always shoots me in games. :/

16. CSarmi is Town - Actually Null, but again for the list. I dont like recent play but the miller claim.. half and half.

 

[v] Chae[/v]

Cs still town getting null. Len been active around thunderdome. Notably pushed for reveal. Mixed stuff tho. Now he does a list where most are NOT sentences

 

Reads Breakdown

 

Thrice

-Scum: Ithillian CSarmi, Turin

-Town: Chaelca, TinaHel, Hallia, Lenlo, Ithillian, CSarmi, Turin (on here twice, thought X was Scum, Dice Town), Despothera, BFG (on Both X and Dice)

Lenlo

-Scum: Chaelca, TinaHel, Ithillian, CSarmi

-Town: Hallia, Lenlo, Despothera, BFG, Turin

Turin

-Scum: Chaelca, Hallia, CSarmi

-Town: TinaHel, Lenlo, Ithillian, Despothera, BFG, Turin

Tina

-Scum: Hallia, Ithillian, Despothera, Turin

-Town: Chaelca, TinaHel, Lenlo, CSarmi, BFG

Despo

-Scum: Chaelca, Hallia, CSarmi

-Town: TinaHel, Lenlo, Ithillian, Despothera, BFG, Turin

Hallia

-Scum: Ithillian, Despothera, Turin

-Town: Chaelca, TinaHel, Hallia, Lenlo, CSarmi, BFG

Chae

-Scum: Lenlo, Despothera

-Town: Chaelca, TinaHel, Hallia, Ithillian, CSarmi, BFG, Turin

Ithi

-Scum: Hallia

-Town: Chaelca, TinaHel, Lenlo, Ithillian, CSarmi, Despothera, BFG, Turin

Thane

-Scum: TinaHel, Lenlo, CSarmi, Despothera, BFG

-Town: Chaelca, Hallia, Ithillian, Turin

Tsuki

-Scum: Chaelca, TinaHel, Hallia, CSarmi, BFG, Turin

-Town: Lenlo, Ithillian, Despothera

BFG

-Scum: Turin

-Town: Chaelca, TinaHel, Hallia, Lenlo, Ithillian, CSarmi, Despothera, BFG

Pral

-Scum:

-Town: Chaelca, TinaHel, Hallia, Lenlo, Ithillian, CSarmi, Despothera, BFG, Turin

Csarmi

-Scum: Ithillian, Turin

-Town: Chaelca, TinaHel, Hallia, Lenlo, CSarmi, Despothera, BFG

NotBob

-Scum: Ithillian

-Town: TinaHel, Hallia, Lenlo, CSarmi, BFG, Turin

@@Chaelca, Despothera Forgot NotBob

 

Out of 14 people, they have the same reads on 9 people, have all three been the only ones to call Turin and Despo scum... All three have cleared each other as town. (And Pral, but so did EVERYONE (kudos, to you and BFG). Split on Thane (kinda had to, didn't you?)... Yeah, next time, maybe want to make sure the patterns aren't obvious, guys?

Tsuki breakdown.

That's about the end of Len play BTW. From then on he just votes me, hounds me and sometimes defend his actions.

I couldn't find where I became scum and why but I may have missed it cause I went page by page instead of ISO.