From the thread most people think Ithi to be helping the town as a third party. Dice has put his word on it, you will see it develop as you read

Dice won as 3rd party. With me. In Arthurian.

well she claimed it really early on. I have a post about it in there as well around 5 or 6 i think.

that is nice to know yates :)

EBWOP: does anyone have a really good reason I should NOT be vote parking on Ithi right now?

Oh I dunno ... maybe because it'd be better to vote for someone you think is mafia maybe?

 

 

I'm a win with Survivor. I just have to live till the end. That's not likely to happen as I'll get Lynched near the end to make sure and so on. If I get too many mafia lynched I'll get NKd.

 

I think it's a lazy/bad look to be talking about vote parking though. Don't you want to have an active vote for some reason?

BFG and Yates, I'm looking forward to seeing your take on the game so far, and the same with Shady's replacement.

I'm getting there. You're the only one that knows why I wasn't around yesterday so I hope this wasn't a jab?

 

8.Yates - he's made one post in the middle of the night where he said he'll be back. I don't think he has been so far, and an unfulfilled promise niggles me big time.

Well, the game started on a Saturday and I had/have family obligations. Are you concerned that I might lurk in a game? Like... ever?

Okay. I'm just starting to read the game now and need to ask something straight off the bat.

Also I'm not actually Town. I'm a 3rd Party Survivor.

Is this a serious hard claim? I see as of page 18 you were sticking to this story:

5.Ithi- I am a third party survivor

I ask because the last two times I allowed a 3rd party survivor to live I won once as scum [with Dice] and lost one as Town [with Arsis replacing Clov]. So, it hasn't worked out so well for Town either time.

 

I don't see a very recent vote count but does anyone have a really good reason I should be vote parking on Ithi right now?

 

 

EBWOP: does anyone have a really good reason I should NOT be vote parking on Ithi right now?

1. She has good skills at finding actual mafia. Since it is early in the game there is no pressure to prioritize 3rd party over mafia. 

2. Her lynch will give less information than any other cause it is easy for mafia to just "park" their votes cause she is not town.

 

The only reason I could see to lynch her today is IF you think she is fibbing and is actually mafia. 

 

All that other stuff is just fearmongering.

 

BFG and Yates, I'm looking forward to seeing your take on the game so far, and the same with Shady's replacement.

I'm getting there. You're the only one that knows why I wasn't around yesterday so I hope this wasn't a jab?

 

8.Yates - he's made one post in the middle of the night where he said he'll be back. I don't think he has been so far, and an unfulfilled promise niggles me big time.

Well, the game started on a Saturday and I had/have family obligations. Are you concerned that I might lurk in a game? Like... ever?

 

Someone sounds very defensive. You could have just come back and posted. I don't recall being privy to your diary. Should I have known where you were?

Sooh don't feel bad. I don't know how to Town Tell really, so me saying I've got nothing on you means you haven't done anything that makes me think your mafia yet.

 

BFG and Yates, I'm looking forward to seeing your take on the game so far, and the same with Shady's replacement.

I'm getting there. You're the only one that knows why I wasn't around yesterday so I hope this wasn't a jab?

 

8.Yates - he's made one post in the middle of the night where he said he'll be back. I don't think he has been so far, and an unfulfilled promise niggles me big time.

Well, the game started on a Saturday and I had/have family obligations. Are you concerned that I might lurk in a game? Like... ever?

 

It wasn't a jab.. it was genuinely what the text says it was. I would very much like for someone to come in with fresh eyes and look at what we have so far.

 

Sooh don't feel bad. I don't know how to Town Tell really, so me saying I've got nothing on you means you haven't done anything that makes me think your mafia yet.

Fair enough. 

 

#PromisesYouPlanToBreak

 

EBWOP: does anyone have a really good reason I should NOT be vote parking on Ithi right now?

Oh I dunno ... maybe because it'd be better to vote for someone you think is mafia maybe?

 

 

I'm a win with Survivor. I just have to live till the end. That's not likely to happen as I'll get Lynched near the end to make sure and so on. If I get too many mafia lynched I'll get NKd.

 

I think it's a lazy/bad look to be talking about vote parking though. Don't you want to have an active vote for some reason?

I'd you intend to keep this claim up and die late game then you're a true liability

 

From the thread most people think Ithi to be helping the town as a third party. Dice has put his word on it, you will see it develop as you read

Dice won as 3rd party. With me. In Arthurian.

 

 

Dice isnt Ithi tho. To me the idea of ithi as Survivor is very like Cory as survivor. That game is what taught me not to instalynch survivor. Ithi is a very good  and fairly obvious mafia hunter. As such I say use her as long as its to towns benefit. Obviously I believe her claim but thats cause I dont see Ithi fakeclaiming survivor. She's too much of a target normally to go and put that on her back willingly.

 

 

and that Arthurian win shattered me lol I did NOT want to win with mafia.

im about to start work but i havent forgotten you seph. I will come back to you but it may not be til i get home tonight

ok

Good evening :)

It's my birthday and family is over. Will check in later tonight. Sorry!

You arrive at work to see multiple ambulances and police tape everywhere. You see your colleagues standing together in a circle by the entrance. As you approach you make out a body right before it is covered by a sheet. Your coworkers fill you in.

Ithi - Third party Survivor with 3x Phase Changer has been killed.

 

 

You see Darthe gave two Town reads and then voted Turin.

 

And then went back and mentioned how suss my post was anyways.

 

Talking both sides too soon.

 

[v]Darthe [/v]

 

Why did you correct the spelling but not the vote Turin?

 

(corrected vote to stop the rest of the post turning red and bold)

 

Young male cows!

 

 

[v]Darthe [/v]

(I lol'ed)

 

 

 

 

 

 

Cory has aged terribly since joining DM.

 

LMAO and SHOTS FIRED!

 

[v] Cory [v/] 

 

No oin e is lock clear. (have I mentioned how much I dislike that term?)

 

Here is my post. When I posted it I saw the last line was illegible to me. So fixed that thing. It distracted me from the lack of color in the failed vote. total squirrel moment.

 

 

Ok 

 

 

Cory

 

You town?

 

i am indeed 

 

i did my job, did you do yours bb?

 

Yup

It's my birthday and family is over. Will check in later tonight. Sorry!

Happy Birthday!

 

 

EBWOP: does anyone have a really good reason I should NOT be vote parking on Ithi right now?

Oh I dunno ... maybe because it'd be better to vote for someone you think is mafia maybe?

 

 

I'm a win with Survivor. I just have to live till the end. That's not likely to happen as I'll get Lynched near the end to make sure and so on. If I get too many mafia lynched I'll get NKd.

 

I think it's a lazy/bad look to be talking about vote parking though. Don't you want to have an active vote for some reason?

I'd you intend to keep this claim up and die late game then you're a true liability

 

Let's think a moment...

 

Questions:

Do you think Ithi is faking her claim as mafia? Then say so and vote her for it.

Do you think she is faking her claim as Town? Then back off cause there must be a reason for it.

Do you think she is telling the truth and is a Survivor that has basically thrown her lot in with town? Then at the very least you should be following along with Cory's (I think) idea that she could always be lynched if we are ever at lylo+1. Or even more to my opinion just treat her as town. If a couple mafia get lynched then they might have to shoot her at night possibly letting a townie live an extra night.

 

Who would want to get the claimed out the gate, pretty much tied to town Survivor lynched as soon as possible? 

 

Final question: Who is she being a liability to? 

VC to come in a bit.

Ithi...         

not sure why everyone is townreading Zander atm but maybe you're right glgl

 

i think i MIGHT be able to read him but i've only seen him once, so glgl me, will have to crank up the Rube Goldberg Soulread Machine

I have Zander as a light town read due to relaxed posting and interaction, easy reads, and although it's a bit generalised I don't see someone who was just lynched Day 1 as town coming in posting when feeling bad and hung over. As with last game it's a muted read due to the fact it's Zander.

Manbat is replacing Shadar.

 

 

would explain the BFG crush

 

 

Ithi - Third party Survivor with 3x Phase Changer has been killed.

Was a good shot, IMO.

 

and that Arthurian win shattered me lol I did NOT want to win with mafia.

And beyond the "phase changer" thing, the bold text is why. Dice may not have WANTED to win with mafia, but it was the only way he COULD win.