Jump to content

9 - 5 Mafia - Day 3 - GAME OVER! MAFIA WINS!

Featured Replies

  • Author

Official Vote Count


 


Tina (1/7) - Darthe


 


Zander (1/7) - Tina


 


Darthe (3/7) - Turin, Zander, Ley


 


Seph (1/7) - Dice


 


Ley (3/7) - Cory, Sooh, Seph


 


Not Voting: Manbat, Yates, BFG, Clov 


 


With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. 


 


Deadline here!


  • Replies 1.9k
  • Views 46.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

In fairness, you are from Norway. This is an AMERICAN 1980's movie classic.

Thank you for giving me the benefit of the doubt lol

I have seen it though, but it was somehow not memorable? *shrug*

 

 

 

Okay, I'm done with it right now. Haven't caught up yet, but Darthe's being so much of an asshole this game that I want him gone, regardless of alignment.

 

[v] Darthe [/v]

Not cool, Ley. Not cool.

 

Not out of his town range though, not even the bold.  I have been an asshole and I have been instigative so it's not as if he can be faulted for disliking it.  

 

@Sooh you're pretty good at figuring out how I approach things and seem really okay with my behavior so far.  If the roles were reversed would that worry you?

 

@Cory I would have expected more from you by now?  I don't really have a reason why.

 

@Turin, I had an issue with You/Ithi because you two screw up my ability to read you when you do your thang.  Now that Ithi is dead I don't have that issue.  Seems sensible to me.

 

 

Unrelated: I've been skimming while at work and feel like someone both held the opinion that I am mafia and that mafia killing Ithi makes more sense than town killing Ithi.  That POV shouldn't add up together since if I were mafia Ithi would have been a lot more valuable to me alive and practically every bit of on thread evidence corroborates that.

 

Can you clarify what you mean by if the roles were reversed?

Zander and Seph should not have votes on right now IMO.  Maybe that's my newbie weakness but I can't figure how either of those are justified.

If I was some unknown player to you and you were someone that everyone was making a fuss over and I essentially ignored it all and said "looks ok to me, moving on" how would you respond to that?  

It's practically validated Turin and I look worse for the death (slightly).

4mZNDa4bdpXLa.gif

 

 

 

 

Okay, I'm done with it right now. Haven't caught up yet, but Darthe's being so much of an asshole this game that I want him gone, regardless of alignment.

 

[v] Darthe [/v]

Not cool, Ley. Not cool.

 

Not out of his town range though, not even the bold.  I have been an asshole and I have been instigative so it's not as if he can be faulted for disliking it.  

 

@Sooh you're pretty good at figuring out how I approach things and seem really okay with my behavior so far.  If the roles were reversed would that worry you?

 

@Cory I would have expected more from you by now?  I don't really have a reason why.

 

@Turin, I had an issue with You/Ithi because you two screw up my ability to read you when you do your thang.  Now that Ithi is dead I don't have that issue.  Seems sensible to me.

 

 

Unrelated: I've been skimming while at work and feel like someone both held the opinion that I am mafia and that mafia killing Ithi makes more sense than town killing Ithi.  That POV shouldn't add up together since if I were mafia Ithi would have been a lot more valuable to me alive and practically every bit of on thread evidence corroborates that.

 

Not valuable though if she was targeting you and only you? I really am just trying to get more information on the subject. as the day kill, was unexpected to me.

I just assumed this was towards me.

 

It wasn't but responding is good so keep at it.  Not valuable.  When you can create a big fuss over nothing and blow it wildly out of proportion both sides tend to look stupid and be ignored.  And it wastes games time.  And people weigh in.  

 

Lots of opportunities to look stupid if that argument is between 3p and mafia so why would a scum team orchestrating something like that cut it off prematurely?  It's practically validated Turin and I look worse for the death (slightly).  Thus those are conflicting views.

 

*sigh* apparently me asking questions is invaluable... I'm just going to drop it.

well that makes me feel a little better :) now I don't have to sulk about playing pokemon

If I was some unknown player to you and you were someone that everyone was making a fuss over and I essentially ignored it all and said "looks ok to me, moving on" how would you respond to that?  

I'm still not sure I completely understand the question, but given the fuss it might be strange that you didn't address it?

 

So what you're saying is that you find it strange that I haven't addressed all the noise between you/Ithi/Turin?

 

I guess I found all of that more of a distraction at the time. I was trying to move the game forward to what I felt was more a constructive kind of assessment work. I am definitely going to go back and read all of it again at a later point in the game to see if I see anything that hasn't already been discussed, but as for my post at this point I feel like the subject is exhausted from my pov. 

We should try to come a consensus ASAP. I don't want to scurry around at the last minute, or even fail the lynch.

 

 

If I was some unknown player to you and you were someone that everyone was making a fuss over and I essentially ignored it all and said "looks ok to me, moving on" how would you respond to that?

I'm still not sure I completely understand the question, but given the fuss it might be strange that you didn't address it?

 

So what you're saying is that you find it strange that I haven't addressed all the noise between you/Ithi/Turin?

 

I guess I found all of that more of a distraction at the time. I was trying to move the game forward to what I felt was more a constructive kind of assessment work. I am definitely going to go back and read all of it again at a later point in the game to see if I see anything that hasn't already been discussed, but as for my post at this point I feel like the subject is exhausted from my pov.

Cool, you seem a bit detached

We should try to come a consensus ASAP. I don't want to scurry around at the last minute, or even fail the lynch.

Strange enough it's often better to wait around and see how people work under pressure

 

 

If I was some unknown player to you and you were someone that everyone was making a fuss over and I essentially ignored it all and said "looks ok to me, moving on" how would you respond to that?

I'm still not sure I completely understand the question, but given the fuss it might be strange that you didn't address it?

 

So what you're saying is that you find it strange that I haven't addressed all the noise between you/Ithi/Turin?

 

I guess I found all of that more of a distraction at the time. I was trying to move the game forward to what I felt was more a constructive kind of assessment work. I am definitely going to go back and read all of it again at a later point in the game to see if I see anything that hasn't already been discussed, but as for my post at this point I feel like the subject is exhausted from my pov.

Cool, you seem a bit detached

 

Detached? On that subject I guess I am... for now at least. 

 

In the game that just finished, he was mafia and pretty much avoided discussing Cass (his only teammate) at all.  It wasn't until we were working on a POE solve that he even brought her up, and he STILL didn't give a read.  

 

Based just on that, I would lean that all three could not be mafia together, and I feel worse about Zander and Dearthe independently than I do Dice.

I'm about 99% sure I've seen Dice bus as scum. I'm sure the Encyclopedia Cortannica can remind us which game if Dice isn't willing to confirm. Not saying Dice is scum but that your logic here may be flawed.

 

 

I bussed Hally in cliche 

 

First off im going to address dice. I am getting used to this, everyone has a different pay style and makes reads differently( the lest field remark) yet it seems you voted me for the sooh comment, and just making a read differently. I feel like I had good reasoning for all my reads.

 

 

 

Dice can you explain your vote on me a little more? I get the gut feeling and that is about all. Around when yoy started posting about me and I was furiously writing my response, there were some posts I really liked, and felt town. I just can't put you there, but I am going back to null.

 

I realized when i went to bed i didnt explain my vote yet i kinda did.  your feel off and  particularly when i read thru corys multiquote of you and especially the fact you took the time to say THE SAME THING twice my gut said you are mafia. hence my vote

 

 

 

No, I had to idea about mafia before dm.

 

So explain why you apparently know zander better then anyone else here? Do you know him from RL?

 

Okay, I'm done with it right now. Haven't caught up yet, but Darthe's being so much of an asshole this game that I want him gone, regardless of alignment.

 

[v] Darthe [/v]

 

@LEY  EDIT THAT ASAP PLZ.   

 

@Darthe  you too plz

I'm soon going to bed and my vote on zander isn't going anywhere.

 

[unvote]

 

 

[v] Darthe [/v]

 

 

I don't get good feelings from Sooh, and I don't think it's just because she is suspicious of me. Can't point at something specific right now. I will have internet at work tomorrow and I will try to read more then. It's not a promise, but I will try.

 

I get a good feeling from Yates.

  • Author

Official Vote Count


 


Tina (1/7) - Darthe


 


Darthe (4/7) - Turin, Zander, Ley, Tina


 


Seph (1/7) - Dice


 


Ley (3/7) - Cory, Sooh, Seph


 


Not Voting: Manbat, Yates, BFG, Clov 


 


With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. 


 


Deadline here!

also what about my posts felt off to you? as this wasn't mentioned when you voted me

@ sooh  if you wanna know why Ithi claimed early?  i have no idea. usually its a claim you make only when you need to as survivor claim = suicide her most of the time

 

 

@Tina  Im kinda there with you. Im not comfy with sooh this game but not sure why

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.