Jump to content

[Blue Ajah Harry Potter Week] HP Mafia 2016 - Gilderoy Lockhart and the Cult of Personality - GAME OVER, TOWN WINS

Featured Replies

 

Wtl Hally or Kat. (Would be based off Luth).

 

I'll be around until about 30 mins till deadline.

What is the likely hood that we are teammates in your opinion.

It's possible. All I can do is work with what we have. So far you and Kat look the worst.

 

Anything else to add/comment on? Not being snarky this time.

  • Replies 809
  • Views 22.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Hally case is ~~~

 

Kaylee, as far as "strong reasons" go, do you think _anyone_ in this game has given enough content to even create a strong case yet?

 

Wtl Hally or Kat. (Would be based off Luth).

 

I'll be around until about 30 mins till deadline.

What is the likely hood that we are teammates in your opinion.

Same question back to you, especially since you're vote is still on me. Cuz if you're argument here is we're T v T then why are you still voting me?

So I'm responding to your "reasons" on me, and you...why do you actually still want to vote me?

I don't agree I was defensive, also the Luth vote reasoning. I get it wasn't a strong reason, your defense that "has anyone given better reasons? " feels off.

 

 

Wtl Hally or Kat. (Would be based off Luth).

 

I'll be around until about 30 mins till deadline.

What is the likely hood that we are teammates in your opinion.

Same question back to you, especially since you're vote is still on me. Cuz if you're argument here is we're T v T then why are you still voting me?

 

I think you gals could absolutely be teammates, given her early defense of you, and your interactions with each other.

Hally case is ~~~

 

Kaylee, as far as "strong reasons" go, do you think _anyone_ in this game has given enough content to even create a strong case yet?

Except when AJ went after me for misunderstanding him? Not really. Hally'S defense of "nobody has had good reasons" strikes a nerve. We can only work with what we got. I haven't placed a vote cuz I don't feel strong enough about anyone yet. Was hoping to have a better feel by now.

 

 

Wtl Hally or Kat. (Would be based off Luth).

 

I'll be around until about 30 mins till deadline.

What is the likely hood that we are teammates in your opinion.

It's possible. All I can do is work with what we have. So far you and Kat look the worst.

 

Anything else to add/comment on? Not being snarky this time.

 

 

So you're saying because we are both scummy looking to you?

 

We're possibly teammates, so you think I would bus that hard that early out of nowhere?

 

So I'm responding to your "reasons" on me, and you...why do you actually still want to vote me?

I don't agree I was defensive, also the Luth vote reasoning. I get it wasn't a strong reason, your defense that "has anyone given better reasons? " feels off.

 

Well, it's my opinion that you came off as defensive with your snark, and I suppose that's a matter of interpretation, and why I voted you.

 

 

 

Wtl Hally or Kat. (Would be based off Luth).

 

I'll be around until about 30 mins till deadline.

What is the likely hood that we are teammates in your opinion.
Same question back to you, especially since you're vote is still on me. Cuz if you're argument here is we're T v T then why are you still voting me?

I think you gals could absolutely be teammates, given her early defense of you, and your interactions with each other.

I don't get your response here. You asked if I thought you and I could be teammates. I asked you the same. You say you and I think Kat?, could absolutely be teammates given our interactions and her early defense of me. I can't speak for the defense. It wasn't planned on my part. Could we both be town, Kat and I? Perhaps.

 

Our interactions? Luth voted weak reasons AJ with me. Then unvoted close after I did for worse reasons. I said as much.

 

I have Kat as my other WTL. Not sure what connection you're trying to make here.

 

 

 

Wtl Hally or Kat. (Would be based off Luth).

 

I'll be around until about 30 mins till deadline.

What is the likely hood that we are teammates in your opinion.
It's possible. All I can do is work with what we have. So far you and Kat look the worst.

 

Anything else to add/comment on? Not being snarky this time.

So you're saying because we are both scummy looking to you?

 

We're possibly teammates, so you think I would bus that hard that early out of nowhere?

Hally i thought you were asking if I thought you and I could be teammates.

 

I think you both look the worst. Doesn't mean you're scum together, but I think at least one of you are. I could be wrong.

 

 

 

Wtl Hally or Kat. (Would be based off Luth).

 

I'll be around until about 30 mins till deadline.

What is the likely hood that we are teammates in your opinion.

Same question back to you, especially since you're vote is still on me. Cuz if you're argument here is we're T v T then why are you still voting me?

 

I think you gals could absolutely be teammates, given her early defense of you, and your interactions with each other.

 

Hallia: by "you gals" do you mean: luthine and kaylee?  I don't get...wait Kaylee just posted a better question of it...

I wouldn't be opposed to Kaylee/Luth(Kat) wagons.

Good cuz we got both. Unless you mean more on both. Guess I'm confused by this since we both already have a train started.

 

lol Lainey... Luthine's vote was a poor choice if she was trying to be "opportunistic" no one that in any way knows AJ in mafia (and I know you don't Kaylee so please don't take this wrong I've just played with him a good bit) thinks that most of the people in here would take his vote to mean anything other than a joke and would vote him for said reason. That train was going no where. I dont' understand the vote at all unless she thought he was being overly defensive about it? 

The fact that it was a poor choice and an easy vote makes it opportunistic.

 

I really wish I had an answer to this.

 

Where IS Kat?

 

I wouldn't be opposed to Kaylee/Luth(Kat) wagons.

Good cuz we got both. Unless you mean more on both. Guess I'm confused by this since we both already have a train started.

 

I haven't looked at a VC in a while... But I would hardly call one vote a wagon

 

 

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

 

Kaylee (1): Hallia

Katiora (1): Dice

 

Not voting (7): Alanna, WiFi, Verbal, Kaylee, Katiora, AJ, Rhea

 

 

Deadline for Day One is Tuesday, 8/2/16 at 9:00 PM PDT/midnight EDT.

 

blu_1470196800.png

 

[v]Katiora[/v]

  • Author

Question for the MOD: DOES EVERYONE HAVE TO VOTE??

There are no special rules requiring voting. The person with the most votes at deadline will be lynched. If there is a tie, random.org will decide the tiebreaker.

I don't see the relevance to asking if two suspects have to fit as partners.

I'm not sure I do either.

Saying two people look the worst is perfectly reasonable, despite their interactions towards each other.

Okay I leave this to y'all, it's time for me to go to bed. My vote on Kat is locked.

 

I would like competing trains on Kat/Kaylee if it can be managed, hopefully I wake up to a lynched wolf

 

Anddd Goodnight!

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

 

Kaylee (1): Hallia

Katiora (2): Dice, Laine

 

Not voting (6): WiFi, Verbal, Kaylee, Katiora, AJ, Rhea

 

 

Deadline for Day One is Tuesday, 8/2/16 at 9:00 PM PDT/midnight EDT.

 

blu_1470196800.png

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.