ReleaseTheEvil

To be fair this isn't such an outlandish idea. D1 Lynch is so much guesswork anyways. May be worth giving someone the benefit of the doubt for it.

That's a good question. Your group is old timers experienced folk. Other group is newer blood/less experienced in Mafia. Based on probabilities and the fact I'm not so sure about the 6 of you, I think at least two of you are scum.

Cause when I mentioned you it felt like you had not posted in about 15 pages and then suddenly poof you magically appear to respond to only my claim, which I might add mentioned almost everyone in the game and didn't single you out.

Something feels very insincere about the people being too nice and trusting of each other. Feels like it is rubbing me the wrong way. The falling over themselves to try to clear each other and trust each other to the death sorta deal.

Process of elimination. I think one of the three of you at minimum is scum. Of the three I think you're most likely the town player though

Sure but that doesn't make you town. Also I didn't tag you in my post, how did you suddenly get to my post among everything you had to catch up with and address it so quickly? Did someone on your team tell you about it and signpost you to it?

No, see OP. Don't think Shad got there in catching up maybe

My daughter had a nightmare so here I am. The votes against me make sense. The Vig fishing was a bad idea but perhaps I over estimated the likelihood of Zander getting lynched today. I thought he had a lot of people's backs up so to speak but under estimated how much his reputation of a good player will give him the benefit of the doubt, at least D1. However as I am town, whether lynched or not let's try to find some scum. My favourite player so far has been Lenlo. I suspect Zander and Lenlo saga is town on town violence but who knows. Definitely not both wolves at least. I think there might be at least one wolf among Verbal, Turin, and Dice. Of the three, maybe I'd go Verbal. Of the three he's done the most posting while playing the game the least IMO. Next another scum between Cass, Cairos, and Gudren. Of the three Gudrean has contributed the most but mostly about herself and telling everyone to be nice and tu or convince us she's a great git player on a sample size of one game. Sorry but that's just luck at this point. Of the three I would probably pick Cairos, very apologetic about being absent because knows as scum it's unfair to quietly sail through based on inactivity? Maybe. Shad I don't know yet. Missing some of their posts now as I type this but so far has the luxury of just summarising things as they catch up. They are good sensible posts though. I feel like I can't remember who else is playing, which I would say is a bad sign for those people and would be among where the third scum is hiding, but I am not mathing right now. Oh Heavy! First posts showed his inexperience but posts have been improving since. Maybe some nice mafia coaching or mentorship in the QT I think right now due to my mistake I am an easy day 1 vote so please watch the possible train on me carefully. Think those who voted me so far are probably town but the rest won't all be. I've unfortunately made an easy case for people to vote me today so my bad.

No I think I agree with you here. Also sorry Gud but someone playing their second game ever and saying they have a gut meta just sounds like they are a liability if they are town. Even people like Dice who say they have a gut feeling are going off a lot more than just their gut. Sorry but that isn't a reassuring thing to hear if you're on my team.

Zander 20% of your posts are FTFM. Can you slow down please?!

This post was your first that really gave me townie feels. Self preservation, indication you can do better in the future, etc etc

Agree with most of this. Dead early a bit strong, but you make playing harder with the way you post tbh

JN, blast from the past as well

Not so sure about last part, why would they have shared knowledge like that?

But watcher still needs to pick the right person to watch (e.g. someone who gets killed) otherwise we get no info. It's a hard role!

But with these roles, watcher will only tell us who visited someone if that person died. And the person who visited them could be mafia or vigilante, and not clear to me if we'd know what the person's role was, or just who person that visited was.

I was going to do a town to scum list, but what strikes me is it's not so much anyone looks scummy right now rather than me being annoyed with Zander's playstyle, which I think is not indicative of his alignment. There are some people who are more quiet who are easily under the radar (even with legitimate reasons for being quiet) and no matter their alignment they aren't gonna get voted today (e.g. Cass, Cairos, etc)

He said something that made me think it, but it's Zander, which means he has 300 posts in this thread already, half of them illegible, and I don't have time to dig it up. It was something about a gun, shooting, firing. Least I thought.

Yes because as town I don't want to lynch the vigilante. Plain and simple. But yes I guess not sure what I thought I would achieve by asking you in that I guess you weren't going to say yes? But trying to avoid a situation where we are near deadline, people arent around, etc and you do a last minute vig claim and then no one is around to react or act accordingly.

Zander Lenlo does have a point though. Can you update your reads list? Your scum list is a bit long it seems at this point for it to make sense.

Sure but as town I'd rather not lynch Zander day 1 and lose the vigilante so....

Forget a night kill or a lynch, these abbreviations will truly be the end of me. I was just too lazy to quote your post where you referenced it and even forgot fishing was a thing.

I am losing my mind with all these abbreviations

I probably shouldn't be asking this, but Zander I don't remember where but did you also hint at you being the vigilante? Something about a gun. While I don't want the mafia to know who the vigilante is, I'd rather we didn't lynch them D1 before they could shoot N1. Besides, if you aren't scum, would be stupid for mafia to kill you.

I mean, it wouldn't hurt. Townies still have plans.