Verbal32

Probably Turin at this point. Forget the 3p slip up, he's confusing the thread with too much WIFOM and literally has our only confirmed townie up in arms wanting him dead. We remove the distraction, which I think is 3p anyway, and move on. D1 is the time to do this, not when a mistake hurts us too much to recover. The above said, I don't feel like this is a mistake.

Thanks, Captain Obvious. If you mean Cass popping into the thread and then bouncing? Not really, she's voting you. Didn't seph already point this out?

And honestly, if a jester is in a game, just lynch them and move on. As a townie, I wouldn't care if the jester won with me, as long as we still beat mafia and other 3p, if applicable. That's my $0.02.

If he was a jester, the game would continue and he'd win along with whatever faction ended the game winning. At least, that's how I would treat a jester.

Please explain what you mean. What does "in the chat" and Gud have to do with the post of Turin's I noted? And that last line is simply silly and NAI at best. Scum would as easily say that as town, and a townie would as easily "run with it" as scum would.

Excellent point here, even though it's aimed at me, heh. For me, I didn't see anything damning enough for me to vote at the time, hence me talking about being confused earlier on when analyzing the train (I think you were the one questioning me on that?). But then he made what appears to be a 3p slip, which when hunting on D1, might be the best I've got thus far. My pings on Darthe and seph are just 1 post as well, I don't have a "body of work" on anybody to say I think they should be the lynch.....just single posts and points that I didn't like. Hope that helps.

While technically true, town is hunting anybody they think is not functioning with the best interests of the town in mind. I read your post as a 3p slip. I see that as not being in the town's best interests, so I'm voting. Simple as that.

Being the first IC to ever be modkilled does carry a certain recognition, though. hehe

If you really think my reaction was twisting, then I'm not sure what to tell ya, dude.

You still haven't addressed the reason I voted - did you or did you not basically say you wanted to win with the town?

Not sure if this is to me or Hallia? Either way, I don't get your meaning.

I literally did.

I find it weird you simply call my vote skeevy and not take into consideration the reason I voted, which I stated. Any input on that, btw?

On D1, as a townie I would gladly take a 3p lynch. Mafia is best case scenario, but at the end of the day removing non-town players is the way to go.

Disagree - town should be hunting everybody not town. On D1, when it's the hardest to hit mafia, if a 3p spews themselves, town should lynch. It's that simple. lol that you think me voting you here means I'm scum

Gonna put Turin against the ropes, here. If 3p, we need to remove ASAP. If I'm misinterpreting something, then I'm willing to listen and revise the impression I just got from that post. Vote: Turin

Huh? I assume this was supposed to say "I wanna win with the town", right? If so, did Turin just spew himself 3rd party? What am I missing here?

Not sure I like DPR as the counterwagon here. I'd prefer one of my top 2, but I don't think I'm getting that. TURIN - 3 (Cass, Zander, DPR) CASS - 1 (Darthe) DPR- 3 (Seph, Hallia, Turin) Not starting a new wagon here, and not voting Cass for reasons already provided. Also not DPR as I mentioned above - seph is in my top 2, and Turin has pretty much done what I did last game and painted a target on himself (for better or for worse). I don't have much of a read on Hallia yet, other than not liking the quick DPR vote without what I feel is a solid reason. That maybe links her with Turin if he flips scum. I'm willing to see if somebody says something ridiculous and outs themselves first, though.

I know this wasn't at me, but I can say I did not read up on it. Theme = flavor, unless the mod says otherwise. And the mod has not said otherwise. TBH any discussion on this topic is meh at best and gaming the mod at worst. Or to put it in the terms of the new gen peeps, "angleshooty".

THUNDERDOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Is this lolcatting, or? I haven't seen the play, so if this is some inside joke....it's meh.

Depends on what you're calling meta in this case? Meta = a player's style? Yes, I do call things out like this all the time - it's part of my style of play. Meta = most effective tactics available? Yes, I do think it's an effective tactic, and I use it. So I guess I should have just said "yes", heh.

And this is the 2nd thing for me - I don't like this. Thinking anybody that has a different POV than you is just likely to be scum is super rigid thinking. Maybe it works for you, but it rubs me the wrong way. Again, just my POV here.

My bad, I think I worded that poorly. You said something that I think is a scumtell - that's what I was saying.