I'm having a hard time reconciling this moment with him being described as a stone... Thoughts?

 

I know Rafe said that he wants to better convey the bond... but... to me, to remain true to Lan's character... if Moraine is crying, Lan should be the one with a single tear rolling down his face, not the other way around.

 

Edited October 28, 20214 yr by TheMountain

8 minutes ago, TheMountain said:

if Moraine is crying, Lan should be the one with a single tear rolling down his face, not the other way around.

Where Are his "tears"?
All I see is anger, rage, and hurt.

Sure, okay, rage and hurt. Doesn't change my point though lol.

I'm waiting for context. Rafe, in his commentary, at least acknowledged how stoic book-Lan is and that this one scene (at least) is a break from that.

When does the scene happen? How young is Lan? What's the context? Who died? Is Moiraine overwhelming Lan with her own emotions? Is this a once-in-a-series thing? Is this what makes Lan the ultimate stoneface? So many questions and no answers.

Also, I assume that's white funeral garb, in keeping with book-culture. Might be post Tarwin's Gap? Though maybe that's too late in the season.

2 minutes ago, Agitel said:

Also, I assume that's white funeral garb, in keeping with book-culture. Might be post Tarwin's Gap? Though maybe that's too late in the season.

That could be Agelmar's funeral if he dies. Baseless speculation ATM

Just now, DaddyFinn said:

That could be Agelmar's funeral if he dies. Baseless speculation ATM

 

That would make sense to me. It seems like a very formal scene, which suggests to me they're not immediately on the run anymore. A funeral, and Lan very upset. So that type of event would make sense. Or maybe just a whole lot of lost life, back in Fal Dara, after Tarwin's Gap.

It looks to me like a ceremonial expression of grief - a context in which such an outpouring is not only permitted but culturally encouraged. 

1 minute ago, Tim said:

It looks to me like a ceremonial expression of grief - a context in which such an outpouring is not only permitted but culturally encouraged. 

You read my mind. I can see it work with Borderlanders even if they are otherwise hard as rock.

Lan lost people on the battlefield in AMoL, and he grieved in his heart but handled it with stone-faced composure. A single salute, a raised fist, a nod, a knee to the ground, perhaps a few wise words, etc... those are the kind of gestures I'd expect.

Edited October 28, 20214 yr by TheMountain

yes, but if they show one single scene where he really loses it for additional impact, it won't impact his character

Just now, king of nowhere said:

yes, but if they show one single scene where he really loses it for additional impact, it won't impact his character

I want to know what lead up to that moment.

 

65% chance, he stubbed his toe hard, or stepped on a lego...

Just now, king of nowhere said:

yes, but if they show one single scene where he really loses it for additional impact, it won't impact his character

Lan shouts at Nynaeve at least once in the books. Sure, it's not the same as screaming in emotional pain but still..

I know it's out of character but I liked it. That was the scene that hit me the hardest in the trailer, emotionally.

 

It takes a lot to make me feel emotions when I consume media. I tend to be pretty detached, especially with visual media (a well written emotional sequence tends to work better for me). But stoic, hardened warrior Lan, crying out in pain? I got chills and nearly teared up.

 

I also agree with the ceremonial aspect of it because of the gesture they all seemed to be making, fist on heart. All in all, pretty cool and really intriguing. I'm into it.

Crying: Acceptable at funerals and The Grand Canyon Tarwin's Gap.

15 minutes ago, Rose said:

I know it's out of character but I liked it. That was the scene that hit me the hardest in the trailer, emotionally.

 

It takes a lot to make me feel emotions when I consume media. I tend to be pretty detached, especially with visual media (a well written emotional sequence tends to work better for me). But stoic, hardened warrior Lan, crying out in pain? I got chills and nearly teared up.

 

I also agree with the ceremonial aspect of it because of the gesture they all seemed to be making, fist on heart. All in all, pretty cool and really intriguing. I'm into it.

 

If this is the one and only time we see Lan like this, and it's a time in the past, perhaps his New Spring days... I can get behind it.

Oh I forgot that it also comes sequentially right after the shot of Valda burning a (presumed) Aes Sedai at the stake, which to me was more viscerally horrifying than all the trollocs and fades put together. So I was coming off of a "wtf NO" and straight into Lan crying out in rage and pain and... Yeah. Perfect emotional cocktail.

 

This trailer made me FEEL things and I'm not sure I'm ready to face the actual show now lol

Edited October 28, 20214 yr by Rose

I thought it was when Moiraine bonded Lan.

 

The Aes Sedai can feel the oaths on them - though they don't have Lan's reaction.  But what if the bond is more painful?  Moiraine is crying because she can feel Lan's pain - very visceral.  But probably even more connected to the fact that he just pledged his life to her - very emotional.

 

I want cookies if I'm right.

Yeah, this is one of those things I want to see in context before I judge it. If Lan breaks like that, it must be something pretty huge and dramatic, especially if Moiraine reacts as well. 

34 minutes ago, DojoToad said:

I thought it was when Moiraine bonded Lan.

 

The Aes Sedai can feel the oaths on them - though they don't have Lan's reaction.  But what if the bond is more painful?  Moiraine is crying because she can feel Lan's pain - very visceral.  But probably even more connected to the fact that he just pledged his life to her - very emotional.

 

I want cookies if I'm right.

 

It looked like a funeral to me, with everyone's dressed in white (the color of mourning in WoT) and the two women on either side of Moiraine look like Nynaeve and Alanna, so it would be in the present timeline. I'm extremely curious what it is.

16 minutes ago, Rose said:

 

It looked like a funeral to me, with everyone's dressed in white (the color of mourning in WoT) and the two women on either side of Moiraine look like Nynaeve and Alanna, so it would be in the present timeline. I'm extremely curious what it is.

Assuming it isn't a trick edit and we won't be seeing 2 such funerals.

9 minutes ago, Skipp said:

Assuming it isn't a trick edit and we won't be seeing 2 such funerals.

 

I wouldn't put any editing trickery past them ?

We should have a RAFO comment for this trailer Rafe and Find Out. He explains this in the video and says outright it is out of character but wanted to show how deep the bond is in sharing emotions

The coolest part about Lan is how little he emotes. That way when he finally does make an emotional reveal it is massively significant. And to be perfectly honest severely stoic personalities aren’t that common in television anymore unless it’s done ironically (Ron Swanson) so I was kinda looking forward to it. In the prequel Lan was extremely stoic when friends die and Moiraine is the one who emotes more or reacts in a more childish ways because his stoicism is so prevalent. She can’t get reactions out of him. I’m not sure I’m about it…but, the only saving grace I will give them is this potentially could be difficult to convey on screen / they could use it as a way to sneakily convey the impact of the bond regardless of his stoicism. “Ohhhh, he is experiencing her emotions on top of his own,” Type thing. Again, not crazy about it but I think I could understand where they are coming from. They are trying to think of ways to show how magic systems impact the world without telling but showing. 

Edited October 29, 20214 yr by JaimAybara