Sorry, I missed your question the first time. I do try to play courteously. I viewed you since you're as good as anybody to view. With the best will in the world, you're a pretty new player (at least, to me) and I find it difficult to tell newbies apart from scum.

 

(and wow, wall of text. I realise that you're caught mafia, but still...)

 

Why I didn't lead a lynch on you immediately today: I'm a busy person on DM, and I play a lot of mafia games. I got things sorted, though.

 

Why wouldn't you reveal? WIFOM. Perhaps you wished to draw the doc investigation?

 

I would urge you to think about some famous movie pairings and realise how my role could implicate other players, before you continue in this foolishness. Oh, wait. You're mafia, of course you'd want to know  ;D

pandy, dude, give it up.  your explinations lack substince and are weak.  i know you want to get lynched, but why try to take the finder down with you dude??

 

meh, i'm a long winded poster.  i do that alot in games.

 

the only pairing your role implies is that there might be batman here.  unless your giong to claim to be batman which would seriously be priceless irony.  then again, we all know Joker has Bats on the brain ;)

 

i hope there is a lie detector in this game to check what i'm saying for a true or false reading.  if so i urge you to send the following quote in for review

 

"I am Forrest Gump, I am Finder for the Town, I am Finder because i'm good at finding Jenny"

 

Ok, I just read through 38 pages, am modding a game and am in 2 games seperate to this and the one I'm modding. And I had a chemistry exam today, so let me get this straight -

 

Red and Pandy have both claimed Cop. Krak is clearly on Pandy's side, and Red is supported by Ed.

 

That sound right?

I'm on Pandy's side too.  For now.

lmao...sorry....Pandy is scummy (in a non town sense). I was on my phone and getting confused.

 

I realized this could go either way. I know who Hermoine {SP?} is. I will reread the last few pages and reconsider voting for Pandy...but I am sure he is non-town.

 

 

Why do you always reveal your role without revealing?  I even know your character now too.

Let's settle this. We lynch Krak today and I hide with either Red orPandy tonight. Sound good? If I die they then who I hide with is mafia. Sound good? After all what is a suicide hider for? I won't reveal to you all who I am hiding with till toward the end of night. End of discussion!

 

No more back and forth I am right you are wrong. You have both stated your cases and I don't think we need another 4 pages of the crap.

sounds good to me min.

 

and yes Rey, you summed it up nicely.

 

 

my vote still stands with Krak.

Ok, I just read through 38 pages, am modding a game and am in 2 games seperate to this and the one I'm modding. And I had a chemistry exam today, so let me get this straight -

 

Red and Pandy have both claimed Cop. Krak is clearly on Pandy's side, and Red is supported by Ed.

 

That sound right?

 

I'm voting for Red because she's leading the mob against me, I'm not necessarily on Pandy's side.

Ok, I just read through 38 pages, am modding a game and am in 2 games seperate to this and the one I'm modding. And I had a chemistry exam today, so let me get this straight -

 

Red and Pandy have both claimed Cop. Krak is clearly on Pandy's side, and Red is supported by Ed.

 

That sound right?

 

I'm voting for Red because she's leading the mob against me, I'm not necessarily on Pandy's side.

 

I never said you were Krak. If you beat the grass, you startle the snakes. Your post helps add a bit more clarity to the picture.

Ok, I just read through 38 pages, am modding a game and am in 2 games seperate to this and the one I'm modding. And I had a chemistry exam today, so let me get this straight -

 

Red and Pandy have both claimed Cop. Krak is clearly on Pandy's side, and Red is supported by Ed.

 

That sound right?

 

I'm voting for Red because she's leading the mob against me, I'm not necessarily on Pandy's side.

 

I never said you were Krak. If you beat the grass, you startle the snakes. Your post helps add a bit more clarity to the picture.

 

Whatever I can do to help  ;D

 

I was just clarifying my position for you (the newcomer)

Ok, I just read through 38 pages, am modding a game and am in 2 games seperate to this and the one I'm modding. And I had a chemistry exam today, so let me get this straight -

 

Red and Pandy have both claimed Cop. Krak is clearly on Pandy's side, and Red is supported by Ed.

 

That sound right?

 

I'm voting for Red because she's leading the mob against me, I'm not necessarily on Pandy's side.

 

I never said you were Krak. If you beat the grass, you startle the snakes. Your post helps add a bit more clarity to the picture.

 

Whatever I can do to help  ;D

 

I was just clarifying my position for you (the newcomer)

 

Maybe you were, maybe you weren't. Actual you were clarifying your position, but why feel the need to do that? Trying to distance yourself from your tag team partner? When it looks like the majority want you lynched? Now why would you want that?

I don't know, next time I won't try to be helpful.  I forgot how much everyone reads into every sentence in this game

And I would like to see where scum means something other than mafia, as no one uses it for anything other than that. Cult are cult and solo winners are just that!

 

Perhaps Kivam will count as someone making a distinction between mafia and scum?  See here:

 

BTW, it's pretty clear to me that Pandy is not mafia (he may or may not be scum, but he's definitely not mafia).

 

Btw, this is from another game going on right now.

Well I guess we will know that red is scum if/when I die and am proven innocent

 

How exactly is that, Krak?  Did she say she viewed you?

 

Honestly, anybody voting for a revealed (not yet confirmed) Finder is horribly suspicious.  Horribly.  The way Pandy is defending himself is making me believe Red, and Wombat jumping in with a vote on Red is nuts.  So you're semi-confirmed not mafia due to Min not dying while hiding....but what about Cult?  Point is, that was a scummy vote.

 

And Krak?  Geesh, even if you're innocent, why would you vote for a potential Finder?  Since when did this become anything remotely resembling a good move?!

Deadline

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch.  You have until a majority is reached or friday at 11 am

 

Vote Count

Krak(7): Red, Ed, Verbal, Alanna, Min, Tigs, Pookie

Red(3): Pandy, Wombat, Krak

 

no vote(5): Aust, TMD, Rey, Talya, Player

 

i left lily off the vote count cause she's frozen and can't vote.

 

 

All right I'm going to partially reveal and try to get some support to either pandy or red. I'm not sure who is finder yet. Maybe they both are...I don't know for sure.

 

But I am Christine. I am supposted to find the Phantom and turn them into an innocent. First night I guessed pandy. And was told that he was a character from the movie "Dark Knight" So I'm assuming that he is either the joker or batman. I'm more likely to think the joker however.

 

On night two I found the Phantom. So we now have one more innocent added to the list and one less mafia scum!

 

Oh and [glow=red,2,300]Krak[/glow] your post sounded HIGHLY like mafia to me.

Why I didn't lead a lynch on you immediately today: I'm a busy person on DM, and I play a lot of mafia games. I got things sorted, though.

 

Hold up.  Is that really your defense?  You're actually sticking with "I'm busy" as a defense for not outting a found mafia?

 

 

 

 

All right I'm going to partially reveal and try to get some support to either pandy or red. I'm not sure who is finder yet. Maybe they both are...I don't know for sure.

 

But I am Christine. I am supposted to find the Phantom and turn them into an innocent. First night I guessed pandy. And was told that he was a character from the movie "Dark Knight" So I'm assuming that he is either the joker or batman. I'm more likely to think the joker however.

 

On night two I found the Phantom. So we now have one more innocent added to the list and one less mafia scum!

 

Oh and [glow=red,2,300]Krak[/glow] your post sounded HIGHLY like mafia to me.

 

I think that proves out Red's claim.  How would she know to state Joker and/or Batman unless it was really part of her role?  That would be a suicide move if she was false revealing.

[glow=red,2,300]Pandy[/glow].

 

I'll trust TMD on this one

Verbal makes a good point about Red's claim being suicide for a mafioso.

 

[glow=red,2,300]unvote[/glow]

[glow=red,2,300]Pandy[/glow]

 

Lynching Krak gains us nothing.  He is very likely innocent and we will have to resolve the finder claims eventually.

:)  

 

thanks TMD, though i hate that you had to reveal.

 

sorry for all the back and forth guys, i was having alot of fun with Pandy's fake role claim against me and wanted to see if i could trip him up.

 

 

Deadline

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch.  You have until a majority is reached or friday at 11 am

 

Vote Count

Krak(8.): Red, Ed, Verbal, Alanna, Min, Tigs, Pookie, TMD

Red(2): Pandy, Krak

Pandy(1): Rey, Wombat

 

no vote(5): Aust, Talya, Player

 

i'm almost positive about krak, but as i havent veiwed him yet i see ya'lls point.  if we don't lynch him, then i will veiw him tonight.  i'm really hoping for the support of the healer though.

 

i leave it up to the town to decide, and we have plenty of time.  though i dont want to switch my vote i do see where resolving the finder dispute will help the town out in the long run.  so even though i don't want to, i'll swallow my pride and switch my vote if need be.

 

 

 

 

Alright I've thought about it and I'm going to reveal something.  I was given an ability last night.  Nae informed me of it but I think it might have come from a player.  The ability is a one time use and allows me to revive someone who has been lynched or nk'd.  Given that I have this ability, I think we should lynch Pandy or Red as one of them is an LLL and therefore scum.  If we lynch scum, we have lynched scum and lent credibility to a finder claim.  If we lynch the finder, then I will revive the finder and we will have a confirmed finder working for us and we will know who to lynch next.  Everyone unvote Krak and vote for one of the potential LLLs.

Verb, That was the first time I have heard anyone call scum something toher than Mafia, and I've been playing for 4 years. So when I see scum I assume you are talking Mafia. It was always used that way when we first played and I ahve only heard it like that!

 

As for the stuff gone on here. either TMD is sticking his neck out backing up Red or Pandy is Mafia. However I do want to ask Red, if she viewed Pandy first night and got the joker (opbvious Mafia or solo role to me) but she comes in blaring that we should go for Krak , because he is Jack Sparrow and the person freezing people!

 

Why would you do that?

 

I'm still thinking Pandy is more likely lying, but I like to know things before I put a vote on!

 

Pandy, I think you should reveal your role name, it doesn't matter if we can work out who the other players maybe called, the important part is that wqe don't know who they are. So your excuse not to reveal, isn't that good!

talya i'm more inclined to lynch krak because i'd rather us do away with another mafia member and worry about a solo winner another time.  for me, lynching scum is more important that a person with a solo win condition, especially if the solo winner isnt a killing role like a vig or SK.

 

i keep saying i'm not sure he's mafia and that i'm going off of his actions alone.  that said if i survive and he isn't lynched i'll know for sure on Day 4 if my hunch is correct. 

 

tayla, everytime you defend krak, you move yourself up higher on my list of suspects.

 

 

wombat, i like your idea.  the only problem i can forsee is if the person has their ability removed if you revive them.  can you see if Nae will clarify that point. 

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote[/glow] Krak for now. Thinking about lynching Pandy, but I'm not sure yet. Wombat's idea sounds good to me.

How about a show of good faith.  If Red thinks someone is mafia besides me, I'll vote for them.  How else can I prove my innocence?  Unless this is a bad idea (tell me if it is), I don't know how else I can prove I'm not 'scum'