Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Dragonmount

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dr Who and Star Wars VS Trekkies Unaffiliated: BSG and Stargate

Who vs SW vs ST 22 members have voted

  1. 1. Dr Who, Star Wars or Star Trek?

    • Dr Who
      20%
      8
    • Star Wars
      35%
      14
    • Star Trek
      17%
      7
    • Stargate
      15%
      6
    • Battlestar Galactica
      10%
      4

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

SG always seemed much more realistic to me for some reason....maybe it's the time difference of it being filmed?

 

And BSG - I haven't watched it all the way through because I've always been a busy little bee and don't tend to just sit and watch tv. I've been watching old Dr. Who episodes while messing on here....yippee?

  • Replies 95
  • Views 2.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

SG always seemed much more realistic to me for some reason....maybe it's the time difference of it being filmed?

 

And BSG - I haven't watched it all the way through because I've always been a busy little bee and don't tend to just sit and watch tv. I've been watching old Dr. Who episodes while messing on here....yippee?

 

All hail the Doctor!

you lot are kidding!! Dr who?? PUHLEASE!!! the Death star kills planets!! a phone box is a goner!!

 

Also when talking BSG i HOPE youre talking the original cause it was AWESOME!! i didnt mind the new one but it got a bit boring

oh and Chewbacca would rip the Doctors arm off in a handshaking accident...

cheers bru

oh and Chewbacca would rip the Doctors arm off in a handshaking accident...

 

BWAHAHAHAHA!!!

you lot are kidding!! Dr who?? PUHLEASE!!! the Death star kills planets!! a phone box is a goner!!

 

Also when talking BSG i HOPE youre talking the original cause it was AWESOME!! i didnt mind the new one but it got a bit boring

 

BSG is cheesy and blows.

 

As has been previously noted, the Doctor is a TIMELORD. He could travel back and change events so that the Death Star never got made!

 

oh and Chewbacca would rip the Doctors arm off in a handshaking accident...

 

Chewy and the Doctor would be best pals and end up playing chess.

As has been previously noted, the Doctor is a TIMELORD. He could travel back and change events so that the Death Star never got made!

 

That's a bit hard when he has already been blown into little tiny bits. You need to be alive to go back and change history. The Doctor is a pansy.

Edited by Basel Gill

As has been previously noted, the Doctor is a TIMELORD. He could travel back and change events so that the Death Star never got made!

 

That's a bit hard when he has already been blown into little tiny bits. You need to be alive to go back and change history. The Doctor is a pansy.

 

No, no, no. He would escape before the Death Star had time to fire its weapon! And then go back in time and set Anakin on a path towards the Light.

 

The Doctor is hot.

Oh, alright. He would escape BEFORE the Death Star fired it's weapon. And NOT tamper with the timeline. Satisfied?

 

Doesn't mean the Angels couldn't get Vader. Eventually. Just saying.

 

Wookies are chess masters. He would win, and the Doctor would graciously congratulate him. They would be drinking Guinneys and laughing about obscure jokes.

 

I say they can all just get along.

 

Except BG. Which still blows.

  • Author

Oh, alright. He would escape BEFORE the Death Star fired it's weapon. And NOT tamper with the timeline. Satisfied?

 

Doesn't mean the Angels couldn't get Vader. Eventually. Just saying.

 

Wookies are chess masters. He would win, and the Doctor would graciously congratulate him. They would be drinking Guinneys and laughing about obscure jokes.

 

I say they can all just get along.

 

Except BG. Which still blows.

Ok, I'm totally adding this to my siggie. You just said I was a chess master. And wookiees would love the doc. THey are tech obsessed and created a space-faring soceity within a millenia or so from one crashed spaceship. The TARDIS wouldn't get destroyed by the Death Star but it would finish Earth off pretty quick. They also don't mess around like the Daleks do.

I voted for Star Wars and StarGate. I grew up on Star wars always have and always will. Star Gate was a great show too. I picked it up earlier this year when i Wife and i were working different shifts. I would spend all 8 hours that she worked to watch SG, cook and puppies that was it!!!!

  • Author

I voted for Star Wars and StarGate. I grew up on Star wars always have and always will. Star Gate was a great show too. I picked it up earlier this year when i Wife and i were working different shifts. I would spend all 8 hours that she worked to watch SG, cook and puppies that was it!!!!

Andrew, you just went from awesome level 2 to awesome level 5. Star Wars FTW!

I voted for Star Wars and StarGate. I grew up on Star wars always have and always will. Star Gate was a great show too. I picked it up earlier this year when i Wife and i were working different shifts. I would spend all 8 hours that she worked to watch SG, cook and puppies that was it!!!!

 

Erm, you were doing WHAT with those puppies?!

Well i guess this is an awkward situtation now

I voted for Star Wars and StarGate. I grew up on Star wars always have and always will. Star Gate was a great show too. I picked it up earlier this year when i Wife and i were working different shifts. I would spend all 8 hours that she worked to watch SG, cook and puppies that was it!!!!

 

Erm, you were doing WHAT with those puppies?!

Well i guess this is an awkward situtation now..... lol nah we got puppies at the same time so i would spend the whole time taking care of them

Edited by Andrew the Asha'Man

BAHAHAHAHAAA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

I laughed so much at that!!!!!!!

 

And also... ... ...BASEL GILL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! DID YOU JUST DARE TO CALL THE DOCTOR A PANSY?!?!?!?!?!

 

I WILL NOT STAND FOR THIS!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

(can you feel my rage yet?)

  • Author

Ooh, this is heating up. I just permission from MG to host an epic Battle of the Fandoms. I'll get it up later on, but be warned this is going to last for a while.

(Fight! Fight! Fight! Fight!)

SG always seemed much more realistic to me for some reason..

 

probably because of the real life weapons, equipment and props (for the SGC at least)

they also had better production crews who knew how to use a tripod...

no offence to the bsg fans but the camerawork made me dizzy

Edited by Ironfishmonger

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.