yeah, it's bad form but not a rule breaker IMO

exactly

It is against the spirit of the game I think, but not necessarily against the rules.

Mods

Like I said in the QT, I think it's a bad idea to have the recruit as the first action in future

 

Tom, sorry I didn't believe you but I didn't think a JOAT would exist, especially after that mayor flip, plus you had lied about night actions on me and stuff.

Ironically I was town at the time. I think I only managed to make one post as cult (last night finished me working 7 days in a row, pretty huge shifts)

Good that that protect early tuesday morning was crucial, I took the first bus to campus at half past five and then came back to sleep. :) Today, Dragonmount started working from at home again.

Edited February 12, 201412 yr by Graendals favourite

I don't recall giving any game info after being hammered

I don't recall giving any game info after being hammered

you didn't.

And most important, I was under the believe you counted as alive until you were actually confirmed dead by the mod.

 

It is against the spirit of the game I think, but not necessarily against the rules.

 

Read rule 5

 

My bad Turin, I thought you talked about having different abilities to recruit or kill after the hammer. Just saying, it kind of sucks for the other people still playing the game when you remove wifom from the whole deal. I realize my penultimate night action would have won me the game but that reveal skewed everything towards town. Combine that with unrecruitable power roles and town became too powerful. It was still a lot of fun. Thanks to the mods. 

Oh and this was my last DM mafia game for the foreseeable future, so thanks everybody for the fun!

 

And most important, I was under the believe you counted as alive until you were actually confirmed dead by the mod.

 

It is against the spirit of the game I think, but not necessarily against the rules.

 

Read rule 5

 

My bad Turin, I thought you talked about having different abilities to recruit or kill after the hammer. Just saying, it kind of sucks for the other people still playing the game when you remove wifom from the whole deal. I realize my penultimate night action would have won me the game but that reveal skewed everything towards town. Combine that with unrecruitable power roles and town became too powerful. It was still a lot of fun. Thanks to the mods.

 

Yea you are right, it's spelled out there pretty clearly.

Then there is not a shred of doubt here whether it was against the rule or not. Personally I believe that even when it is not spelled out so directly, it's really bad form and against the spirit of the game to do so.

Oh and this was my last DM mafia game for the foreseeable future, so thanks everybody for the fun!

I'm sad to hear that, I think you're a great player.

Actually it's not that simple, now that I think about it. For instance, Chaelca hammered Turin on D1 with her secret doublevote.

 

Now if it wasn't for the mods being around at that moment, Turin wouldn't know he was hammered...

GG all well done town!

 

 im not seeing how GF dieing N6 would give Golden the game. He was still outnumbered and i viewed him so me aand tommy would have lynched him anyway.

 

Can we get mafia QTS?

Pretty sure they were talking about N5.

ahhh  that makes more sense

 

I was sweating that theyd kill GF from the moment he claimed.

 

In response to the Dead thread  I didnt want to bring up unrecruitable unless i had to    too easy to give mafia info they may not have had.  I was also real nervous about GF actually BEING recruitable and having been recruited immediately after claiming  I have seen cult games wher one of the doc/cop duo was recruitable and the other wasnt   i got recruited as a Doc at one point

Dead Thread: http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/CCqtpbcY5CU

 

There were multiple mafia QTs. So if Turin, Darthe and GE are willing to share their respective QTs, I can do that.

 

@Dice I meant N5, not N6, sorry. If GE had killed GF, that would have left Tommy, Dice, Ley and GE in the game. Dice had viewed Ley and he would have been mostly lynched. Then all GE had to do was night-kill either Tommy or Dice. Instead, GE killed Dice but Dice was protected by GF. 

GF really saved the game by protecting me all the time

I'm good with mine not.much there Tbh

GF is a better player than many give him credit for. I've seen him save more than one game in real style.

I nearly killed him n1... I still would have lost but it.might have ended differently

could you have gotten through his self protect?

 

And most important, I was under the believe you counted as alive until you were actually confirmed dead by the mod.

 

It is against the spirit of the game I think, but not necessarily against the rules.

 

Read rule 5

 

My bad Turin, I thought you talked about having different abilities to recruit or kill after the hammer. Just saying, it kind of sucks for the other people still playing the game when you remove wifom from the whole deal. I realize my penultimate night action would have won me the game but that reveal skewed everything towards town. Combine that with unrecruitable power roles and town became too powerful. It was still a lot of fun. Thanks to the mods. 

 

 

Maybe I'm wrong, but "leeway" sounded like "a bit stretchable" to me, and there are two more things that come with that. First, I was under the believe that the lynch was not there when you were hammered, but when the mod came to say that you were, and the second is what made me think that: There are roles that mess with votes. It is entirely possible that there's a role that makes a vote not count. And, as I said already, I would have given the info between the second and the third vote if I had been online.

lol nope.

According to the dedthred he protected me n1. Maybe I read it wrong.

I didn't read it... oh wow that was not predictable...