BS was never going to get it right when Rj even got a few things wrong in the later books.  I always said it seems like 5 or 6 years should of gone by,

2 hours ago, DemandredFO said:

It's not surprising that Brandon got the timeline wrong considering the mess it was in. RJ probably only knew it all because he wrote it but he might not have had notes on it for anyone else to follow.

You... you cant possibly have taken me seriously about Bela being a magic wardrobe horse and Sanders and Harriet hiring champions for a lip sync battle, can you?

 

That thing about The Rock being a champion lip sync contender with Shake It Off though? That was real. Your life will be enriched if you look it up. Like he plays it so well it makes you believe he'd be doing that on his own time just for fun.

8 hours ago, Sabio said:

BS was never going to get it right when Rj even got a few things wrong in the later books.  I always said it seems like 5 or 6 years should of gone by,

One of the reasons for that is that the bulk of the time elapses in the first six books. If all the books covered a similar length of time it would be that sort of time.